Cold water is a real stressor. If you have a heart condition or high blood pressure, are pregnant, or take medication that changes how you handle cold, talk to your doctor before you start. Never plunge alone or after drinking.

Quick answer

A cold plunge is not exercise and doesn’t replace any. A 5-minute plunge burns about 5 to 25 extra calories for a 180 lb adult; 10 minutes of moderate rowing burns about 57. What the plunge does well is different: it wakes you up, takes the edge off soreness and, in hot weather, can help you hold a pace. The real question is order. Plunge before strength work like rows, face pulls, presses and muscle-ups, or on another day. After conditioning like sled pushes, stair climbing, rowing and shadow boxing, plunge whenever you like.

People search “cold plunge vs sled push” or “face pulls vs cold plunge” as if they were rivals for the same 20 minutes. They aren’t. One trains you; the other changes how you feel and recover. Our verdict up front: if you only have time for one, train. Then use the plunge where it helps that session instead of hurting it.

Calories: not close

Here is the extra energy each one burns over 10 minutes, above what you’d burn sitting still, for a 180 lb adult. Exercise figures use METs from the 2024 Adult Compendium of Physical Activities (Herrmann, 2024), the standard reference researchers use; the plunge range is from our ice bath calorie calculator, which shows its working from two published measurements.

Extra calories in 10 minutes, 180 lb adult

ActivityCompendium entryExtra calories
Cold plunge, 50 to 59°FNot listed; from our calorie calculator9 to 50*
Tai chiTai chi, qi gong, general (15670)about 33
Face pulls, barbell rows, overhead press, calf raisesResistance (weight) training, multiple exercises, 8 to 15 reps (02054)about 36
Heavy lifting, big setsResistance training, power lifting or body building, vigorous (02050)about 71
Rowing machine, easy to moderateRowing machine, under 100 watts, moderate (02071)about 57
Stair climbingStair climbing, general (17131)about 83
Rowing machine, hardRowing machine, vigorous (02070)about 90
Muscle-ups and pull-upsCalisthenics (push-ups, pull-ups, jumping jacks, burpees), vigorous (02020)about 93
Shadow boxingBoxing, simulated boxing round, exercise (15125), the closest entryabout 119

*Ten minutes of plunging is long; most people stay 3 to 5 minutes, which is about 3 to 25 extra calories. Exercise numbers assume you keep moving for the full 10 minutes at that effort, which sets don’t do. The Compendium has no entry for sled pushes, so we left them out rather than guess. Even so, a few minutes of almost anything on the list out-burns a plunge.

Cold water does raise your metabolism, sometimes a lot: an hour neck-deep in 57°F water lifted it 350% in a classic lab study. But nobody plunges for an hour, and the extra in a 3 to 5 minute dip is small. Plunge for how it makes you feel and recover, not for calories.

What a plunge does that a workout doesn’t

  • An alertness hit in minutes. In a 12-week study, 20-second dips in 32 to 36°F water doubled or tripled noradrenaline every time.
  • Less soreness over the next few days. Across 17 small trials, plunging after hard exercise cut muscle soreness at 24 to 96 hours compared with resting (Cochrane review).
  • A better mood. Five minutes in about 57°F seawater lifted mood as much as twenty in a 2026 trial of 140 adults.
  • A head start in the heat. Cooling down before exercise in hot conditions improved endurance performance by 6.6% on average in a meta-analysis of 27 trials, against 1.4% in moderate temperatures. Short sprints barely changed. In that analysis, water cooling on its own had one of the smaller effects (1.2%), and a second meta-analysis found combined methods worked best, so treat a pre-run plunge in July as a bonus, not a strategy.

None of that builds muscle, raises your aerobic fitness or burns meaningful fat. That is the exercise’s job.

Move by move: plunge before, after, or either

The rule with the strongest evidence is simple: cold water in the minutes after strength training costs you some of what that session would have built. In a 12-week trial, men who finished each lifting session with 10 minutes of cold water gained less strength and muscle than men who did an easy bike ride instead, and a 2024 meta-analysis of 8 studies found the same. Aerobic work is different: a 2021 meta-analysis found regular cold water after training had no effect on gains in aerobic power or time-trial performance.

One caution from the manuals, not the studies: three of the plunge manuals we hold, Kohler’s, Icetubs’ and Finsauna’s AquaFin, warn against getting in immediately after strenuous exercise. AquaFin’s says to wait until your muscles have relaxed or your heart rate has returned to normal. A few minutes of easy walking first costs you nothing.

Move by move: where the plunge goes

Your sessionPlunge before?Plunge after?Why
Barbell rows, face pulls, overhead pressYes, then a real warm-upNot if size or strength is the goalCold water right after lifting cut strength and muscle gains in trials
Muscle-ups and pull-upsOnly with a long warm-up, hands kept dryNot if strength is the goalCold hands lose grip: 13 to 16% weaker after 41°F water
Calf raisesYes, the one move with a direct testNot if size is the goalLifters added load after a 5-minute plunge at 50°F in a small 2025 trial
Sled push, stair climbing, rowingIn hot weather, it can helpYes, once your breathing settlesCold water after training didn’t blunt aerobic gains
Shadow boxing, intervalsWarm up well first; fast moves suffer mostYes, after a short cooldownCold muscle loses 4 to 6% of power per 1°C it cools
Tai chi, mobility, stretchingEitherEitherLow intensity; no evidence it changes anything either way

Two details matter for the “before” column. Cold muscle is weaker until it rewarms: in classic lab work, strength and power fell 4 to 6% for every 1°C (1.8°F) drop in muscle temperature, and in a leg-cooling study fast movements lost far more than slow ones. And cold hands grip worse: hands held in 41°F water lost 13 to 16% of their grip strength. So keep your hands on the rim, and give the warm-up real time before the first heavy set or the first explosive round.

Calf raises are the one move on the list with a direct test. In a small 2025 trial of 24 trained lifters, the group that sat in 50°F water for 5 minutes first added more load from their first set to their second (94.5 to 98.0 kg) than the group that didn’t, and showed signs of fatigue later. One study, one muscle, but it fits what Dr. Kirk Parsley describes from his own training.

His fix for lifters, on Brian Cain’s podcast, is to move the plunge in front of the session and then warm up properly, because after about five minutes in cold water your limbs stay cooler for an hour or two:

“The temperature of your limbs at the very least, but probably your core temperature will stay a little bit lower for probably an hour to two hours.”

Dr. Kirk Parsley, on Brian Cain’s podcast

The full breakdown, with the clips, is in cold plunge before or after a workout.

Three ways to put them in the same day

Plunge and workout in one day

DayOrderWhy it works
Lifting for size or strengthPlunge in the morning, lift in the afternoon; or plunge, warm up 15 minutes, then liftKeeps cold water out of the hours right after the session
Conditioning: sled, stairs, rowing, boxingTrain, then plungeSoreness relief without a cost to aerobic gains
Hot day, long effortA short plunge, then goPre-cooling helped endurance in the heat; skip it before short sprints

If there’s a sauna in the mix, sauna or cold plunge first covers the order, and sauna vs exercise covers whether a sauna session can stand in for cardio (it can’t, but it does more than a plunge). For the heat side of this page, see sauna before or after a workout.

Safety

Get in slowly, keep your head out, never plunge alone and skip it after drinking. If you have heart disease or high blood pressure, talk to your doctor first. Who should cold plunge goes through the exceptions, and how to do a cold plunge correctly covers the basics.

FAQ

Is a cold plunge better than a workout?

No. They do different jobs. A workout builds muscle and fitness; a plunge wakes you up, eases soreness and can lift your mood. Ten minutes of moderate rowing burns about 57 extra calories for a 180 lb adult, against about 5 to 25 for a 5-minute plunge.

Does a cold plunge count as exercise?

No. Cold water raises your heart rate and metabolism for a few minutes, but it doesn’t load your muscles or train your aerobic system. Count it as recovery.

Should I cold plunge after upper-body lifting like rows and face pulls?

Not if size or strength is the goal. Plunge before the session and warm up, plunge in the morning and lift later, or plunge on a rest day.

Is a cold plunge good after cardio, like stair climbing or a sled push?

Yes, once your breathing has settled. Regular cold water after training didn’t blunt aerobic gains in a 2021 meta-analysis, and it can ease soreness over the next few days. Several plunge makers warn against getting in immediately after strenuous exercise, so cool down for a few minutes first.

Can I cold plunge instead of working out on a rest day?

Yes, as recovery, not as a replacement. A rest-day plunge is the one time the timing question disappears.

Does cold water before exercise hurt performance?

For strength, power and fast moves, a little, until you rewarm: about 4 to 6% per 1°C of muscle cooling. Warm up well. For endurance in hot weather, pre-cooling helped by about 6.6% on average.

Sources

  1. Herrmann SD et al. 2024 Adult Compendium of Physical Activities: a third update of the energy costs of human activities. J Sport Health Sci, 2024. Source
  2. Srámek P et al. Human physiological responses to immersion into water of different temperatures. Eur J Appl Physiol, 2000. Source
  3. Leppäluoto J et al. Effects of long-term whole-body cold exposures on plasma concentrations of ACTH, beta-endorphin, cortisol, catecholamines and cytokines in healthy females. Scand J Clin Lab Invest, 2008. Source
  4. Bleakley C, McDonough S, Gardner E, Baxter GD, Hopkins JT, Davison GW. Cold-water immersion (cryotherapy) for preventing and treating muscle soreness after exercise. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2012. Source
  5. Kelly JS et al. Improved mood following cold-water immersion: a comparison of differing exposure durations. Lifestyle Medicine, 2026. Source
  6. Wegmann M et al. Pre-cooling and sports performance: a meta-analytical review. Sports Med, 2012. Source
  7. Bongers CC et al. Precooling and percooling (cooling during exercise) both improve performance in the heat: a meta-analytical review. Br J Sports Med, 2015. Source
  8. Roberts LA et al. Post-exercise cold water immersion attenuates acute anabolic signalling and long-term adaptations in muscle to strength training. J Physiol, 2015. Source
  9. Piñero A et al. Throwing cold water on muscle growth: a systematic review with meta-analysis of the effects of postexercise cold water immersion on resistance training-induced hypertrophy. Eur J Sport Sci, 2024. Source
  10. Malta ES et al. The Effects of Regular Cold-Water Immersion Use on Training-Induced Changes in Strength and Endurance Performance: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis. Sports Med, 2021. Source
  11. Bergh U et al. Influence of muscle temperature on maximal muscle strength and power output in human skeletal muscles. Acta Physiol Scand, 1979. Source
  12. Sargeant AJ. Effect of muscle temperature on leg extension force and short-term power output in humans. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol, 1987. Source
  13. Vincent MJ et al. The effects of cold immersion and hand protection on grip strength. Aviat Space Environ Med, 1988. Source
  14. Tillaar RVD et al. The Acute Effect of Warm-Up with Cold Water Immersion upon Calf Raise Performance, Muscle Tension, and Oxygen Saturation. J Funct Morphol Kinesiol, 2025. Source