Quick answer

The Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller is the better choice than the Coldture Water Chiller Pro for a tub that only needs to be cold, and the Coldture Pro is the better choice when you also want warm water from the same tub. The Penguin publishes 7,500 BTU/hr of cooling on just 3.9 amps, is rainproof for outdoor use above freezing, and costs noticeably less. The Coldture Pro cools to 37°F, heats to 104°F, and runs from an app over 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi. Both have a built-in pump and filter and run on a standard 120 V outlet.

At a glance

Penguin Chillers

Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller (Cold Plunge Chiller and Filter Kit)

7,500 BTU/hr cool-only on 3.9 amps

Type
Cool-only plunge chiller (built-in pump)
Price tier
Mid
Best for
Existing tubs that only ever need to be cold

Choose the Penguin if you want 7,500 BTU/hr of cool-only chilling on 3.9 amps for an existing tub and never need warm water.

Coldture

Coldture Water Chiller Pro

Heats and cools 37 to 104°F with app control

Type
Heat and cool plunge chiller (built-in pump)
Price tier
Premium
Best for
One tub for a cold plunge and a warm soak, run from your phone

Choose the Coldture Pro if you want one unit that cools to 37°F and heats to 104°F, with app control and a timer.

These are two of the add-on chillers people compare most when they already have a tub, or want to pick their own. They solve the same problem differently. The Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller is a cool-only, 3/4 HP unit built in Tennessee with a pump in the cabinet. The Coldture Water Chiller Pro is a heat-and-cool unit with its own pump, filter housing, strainer, built-in GFCI and an app.

Plunge Junkies sold Penguin chillers for years, so we have seen what happens after delivery: placement and priming questions, units that would not cool, and warranty boxes going back to Tennessee. Coldture is newer to us, with no support history yet, so everything about it here is from the manual and the maker's listings, on paper.

Key differences between Penguin and Coldture Pro

  • Lowest set temperature: Penguin 37 °F, Coldture Pro 37 °F.
  • Running current: Penguin 3.9 A, Coldture Pro 8 A.
  • Dry weight: Penguin 49 lb, Coldture Pro 66.1 lb.
  • Cabinet length: Penguin 17 in, Coldture Pro 24.2 in.
  • Standard warranty: Penguin 1 year, Coldture Pro 1 year.
  • Best for: Penguin: Existing tubs that only ever need to be cold. Coldture Pro: One tub for a cold plunge and a warm soak, run from your phone.

Penguin vs Coldture Pro by the numbers

Head to head: the numbers that matter

PenguinColdture Pro

Lowest set temperature[1]

Penguin37 °F
Coldture Pro37 °F

Lower is better · Both list 37°F; Penguin says low to mid 40s is the normal holding range

Running current[5]

Penguin3.9 A Edge
Coldture Pro8 A

Lower is better · Penguin 3.9 A at 450 W; Coldture 8 A on a standard 15 A outlet

Dry weight[5]

Penguin49 lb Edge
Coldture Pro66.1 lb

Lower is better · Matters when you drain it and carry it inside for winter

Cabinet length[5]

Penguin17 in Edge
Coldture Pro24.2 in

Lower is better · Penguin 17 x 15 x 13 in; Coldture 24.2 x 13.1 x 18.9 in

Standard warranty[1]

Penguin1 year
Coldture Pro1 year

Higher is better · Penguin sells 2- and 3-year extensions; Coldture offers options to extend

How cold do bathhouses actually run? (SaunaShare data)

Coldest tub at each of the 65 SaunaShare bathhouses that publish a plunge temperature, out of 403 listings with a cold plunge. Median: 45°F.

Below 40°F9 bathhouses
40 to 44°F15 bathhouses
45 to 49°F25 bathhouses
50°F and up16 bathhouses

Lowest published setting: Penguin 37°F, Coldture Pro 37°F. Most bathhouses run warmer than either floor.

Our scorecard (1 to 5, from published specs and our support history)
CategoryPenguinColdture Pro
Published cooling dataPenguin rates 7,500 BTU/hr; Coldture publishes no cooling rate in the manual or listings we read.5/52/5
Electrical drawThe Penguin runs on 3.9 A and 450 W; Coldture's manual asks for a 15 A minimum circuit and the maker rates it at 8 A.5/53/5
Hot and cold versatilityPenguin says its chillers do not heat; the Coldture Pro heats to 104°F.1/55/5
Setup and placementThe Penguin must gravity-prime within 3 feet of the tub drain; the Coldture Pro purges its own air in 2 to 3 minutes at startup.3/54/5
ControlsThe Coldture Pro adds the Tuya Smart app, a timer and child lock; the Penguin has an on-unit controller only.2/55/5
Simplicity and fewer failure pointsA cool-only machine has one job; on combo units, heating is the side we have seen fail most.5/53/5

Category ratings, not a total: which one wins depends on which rows matter to you.

Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller (Cold Plunge Chiller and Filter Kit) vs Coldture Water Chiller Pro: full specifications

SpecPenguin Cold Therapy Chiller (Cold Plunge Chiller and Filter Kit)Coldture Water Chiller Pro
Sold as[2]3/4 HP high efficiencyNot listed by horsepower
Published cooling[1]7,500 BTU/hrNot published
Heating[5]None (cool only)Yes, to 104°F
Temperature range[1]37 to 100°F operating range with water; cools only37 to 104°F, heats and cools
Electrical[5]110 to 120 V, 450 W, 3.9 A, single phase120 V (rated 110 to 120 V), 8 A, standard 15 A household outlet
GFCI[3]GFCI-protected cord (6 ft per Penguin's page; distributor overview says 10 ft)Built-in GFCI with test button, test before each use
Pump[1]Built in; not self-priming, must gravity-primeBuilt in; purges air for 2 to 3 minutes at startup
Filtration[1]Inline screen; optional install/filter kit adds a washable 150-micron filter, tubing and bulkheadsContinuous internal filtration plus an external strainer; manual says replace the filter monthly
Ozone[5]None listedBuilt in, per Coldture's page
Tub connections[1]3/4 in camlocks; kit bulkheads fit tub walls 1/4 in or lessSupplied hoses thread onto the tub's water in and water out fittings
Controls[3]On-unit digital controllerOn-unit display plus Tuya Smart app over 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi, with timer and child lock
Refrigerant[1]R-32Not published
Outdoor use[1]Outdoor rated above 32°F; disconnect and drain at freezingNo outdoor rating stated in the manual we read
Noise[1]56 dBANot published (described as low-noise)
Size[5]17 x 15 x 13 in24.2 x 13.1 x 18.9 in
Weight[5]49 lb66.1 lb dry, 77.1 lb packaged
Warranty[5]1 year; 2- and 3-year extensions sold1 year with options to extend (manual: 1 year from ship date, residential only)
Made in[1]Knoxville, Tennessee, USANot published

Cooling: the number only one of them publishes in full

The Penguin is rated at 7,500 BTU/hr from a 3/4 HP high efficiency unit with a titanium coil. That is the spec that tells you whether a chiller can beat the heat leaking into your tub on the hottest week. Coldture does not publish a cooling rate in the manual or listings we read, so you cannot compare the two on the number that matters most. Coldture's manual adds one practical figure: the tub reaches minimum or maximum temperature in about 3 hours, depending on air temperature and set point.

Penguin's own overview is candid about real-world results. It says the chiller can reach the low 40s and even the high 30s in the right conditions, and that the low to mid 40s should be possible on most setups of about 100 gallons even in full sun. It also says the sun, not your body, is most of the heat load, so shade and a cover do more than any spec sheet.

Our view: size for 45°F. Of the 39 public saunas and bathhouses on SaunaShare that publish their plunge temperature, the coldest tub typically runs about 45°F and only 5 run anything below 40°F. Either chiller can hold that on an insulated, covered tub. The chiller sizing guide shows how to check your own tub's heat gain.

Heat or no heat: the real decision

This is the question that should decide it. Penguin says plainly that its chillers do not heat. The Coldture Pro heats to 104°F, so one tub can be a cold plunge in the morning and a warm soak at night, and the app timer can switch it for you.

That flexibility comes with a cost: one box doing two jobs. The Coldture manual even notes the unit may keep running after you change the set point, because it switches between cooling and heating and overshoots slightly before it cycles off. That is normal behavior, but it is more running than a cool-only unit does.

If you never want warm water in the plunge, the Penguin's single job is an advantage, not a gap.

Setup, pump and placement

Both have the pump built in, which is the main reason to buy either over a bare hydroponics chiller. The difference is how fussy the pump is.

  • Penguin: the pump is not self-priming. Penguin says to place the chiller within 3 feet of the tub drain with its bottom at or below the bottom of the tub, never elevated, and warns that a long tubing run can starve the pump.
  • Coldture Pro: hoses thread onto the tub's water in and water out fittings, hand tight. At power-on the unit purges air for 2 to 3 minutes and shows a flow error if valves are closed or a fitting leaks air.

Both move heat into the air around them. Penguin says a chiller in a closet or cabinet cannot work properly. Give either one open air on every side.

Size, weight and living with it

The Penguin is the smaller box: 17 by 15 by 13 inches and 49 lb. The Coldture Pro is 24.2 by 13.1 by 18.9 inches and 66.1 lb dry, 77.1 lb in its carton. That difference matters twice a year if you live somewhere cold, because both chillers should be drained before a freeze and a lighter unit is easier to carry inside.

Day to day, the Coldture is the more connected machine. The manual walks through pairing it with the Tuya Smart app, which only works on a 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi network, then setting on and off times from your phone. It also has a child lock and a flow readout on the display. The Penguin has an on-unit controller and nothing else, which is all a cool-only chiller running around the clock needs.

Penguin publishes a 56 dBA sound rating. Coldture describes the Pro as low-noise but publishes no decibel figure. Both chillers blow warm air out of the cabinet, so put either one where the exhaust can escape and the noise will not bother anyone.

Power and the outlet you have

The Penguin draws 3.9 A and 450 W on 110 to 120 V, with a GFCI-protected cord. That shares a standard 15 A household circuit comfortably. The Coldture Pro runs on 120 V, 60 Hz and its manual asks for a grounded outlet on a 15 A minimum circuit, with the maker rating it at 8 A. It has a GFCI built into the unit, with a test button the manual says to press before each use.

At the Coldture's higher draw, a dedicated circuit is worth considering, especially if heat mode runs on the same circuit as other loads. For either one, use a licensed electrician for any new outlet, the same as you would for a sauna heater.

Safety: Keep the plug off the ground and away from water. Coldture's manual says not to permit any electric appliance within 5 feet of the tub. Never use a chiller whose GFCI test fails.

Water care and maintenance

Both filter the water as they circulate it. The Penguin has an inline screen, and its optional install and filter kit adds a washable 150-micron filter, two 6-foot lengths of 3/4 inch tubing and bulkheads that fit tub walls 1/4 inch thick or less. Penguin says not to use a filter rated below 50 microns. It also says a timer is not recommended: the pump should run continuously, and frequent power cycling adds wear.

The Coldture manual lays out a weekly routine of about 15 minutes: check water chemistry, clean the external strainer, check the water filter. It says to replace the filter monthly for best results and to sanitize the system by running heat mode at 104°F through a bucket during deep cleaning. Coldture's page adds that b.uilt-in filtration and ozone continuously cycle and purify your plunge every 15 minutes

Whichever you buy, keep the condenser clean. The most expensive chiller repair we have handled was a compressor that died because the coil was packed with dirt. Our clean water guide covers sanitizer for either setup.

Outdoors, winter and warranty

Penguin calls the Cold Therapy Chiller outdoor rated and rainproof for air temperatures above 32°F, and says to disconnect and drain it completely if the air drops to freezing or below. Coldture's page describes the Pro's low-noise performance as suiting setups indoors or outdoors, but the Pro manual we read states no outdoor rating and no freezing rule, so ask Coldture before you leave it outside for winter. Read how to keep a cold plunge from freezing before an outdoor install in a cold state.

On warranty, Penguin includes 1 year and sells 2- and 3-year extensions. Coldture's page lists a 1-year warranty with options to extend, while the Pro manual we read says 1 year from ship date for residential use only, with Coldture covering shipping on a legitimate claim. Both exclude commercial or rental use.

The verdict

Which one should you buy?

Choose Penguin if

  • You only ever want cold water
  • Your outlet is shared and every amp counts
  • You want a published BTU/hr rating to size against your tub
  • You want a chiller with fewer jobs that can fail

Choose Coldture Pro if

  • You want the same tub warm at night and cold in the morning
  • You want to set the temperature and timer from your phone

Choose the Penguin if you want 7,500 BTU/hr of cool-only chilling on 3.9 amps for an existing tub and never need warm water. Choose the Coldture Pro if you want one unit that cools to 37°F and heats to 104°F, with app control and a timer.

FAQ

Is the Penguin or the Coldture Chiller Pro better?

The Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller is better for a tub that only needs cold water, because it publishes 7,500 BTU/hr of cooling on 3.9 amps and has one job. The Coldture Water Chiller Pro is better when you want hot and cold from the same tub, since it heats to 104°F and cools to 37°F with app control.

Does the Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller heat water?

No. Penguin says its chillers do not offer heating, so the Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller is cool-only. If you want warm water from the same unit, the Coldture Water Chiller Pro heats to 104°F.

How much power do the Penguin and Coldture chillers draw?

The Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller draws 3.9 amps and 450 watts on 110 to 120 volts. The Coldture Water Chiller Pro runs on 120 volts and its manual asks for a grounded outlet on a 15 amp minimum circuit, with Coldture rating it at 8 amps. Both should be plugged into a GFCI-protected outlet.

Can the Penguin or Coldture chiller be used outside?

The Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller is rainproof for outdoor use but must be disconnected and fully drained when air temperatures reach freezing. Coldture's page describes the Coldture Water Chiller Pro as suiting setups indoors or outdoors, but the manual we read states no outdoor rating or freezing rule, so confirm with Coldture before leaving it outside in winter. Either way, plan for winter before it arrives.

How cold do the Penguin and Coldture chillers get?

Penguin lists 37°F as the lowest recommended operating temperature for the Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller, and the Coldture Water Chiller Pro sets down to 37°F. Penguin's overview says most setups of about 100 gallons can hold the low to mid 40s even in full sun. Public bathhouses on SaunaShare typically run their coldest plunge at about 45°F.

What warranty do the Penguin and Coldture Pro chillers have?

The Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller includes a 1-year warranty, and Penguin sells 2- and 3-year extensions. The Coldture Water Chiller Pro manual gives 1 year from the original ship date for residential use, with Coldture covering shipping on a legitimate claim; Coldture's current page lists a 1-year warranty with options to extend. Check the current terms at purchase.

Sources we checked

Specifications were read from these documents on November 14, 2026. Makers change models; check the current manual before you buy.

  1. Penguin Chillers: Cold Therapy Chiller product page and spec table (read Nov 14, 2026)
  2. Penguin Cold Therapy Chiller overview and FAQ (Leisurecraft distributor PDF)
  3. Coldture Water Chiller Pro user manual v1.0 (hosted by Sauna Marketplace)
  4. Sauna Marketplace: Coldture Water Chiller Pro listing (read Nov 14, 2026)
  5. Coldture: The Cold Plunge Water Chiller Pro product page (read Nov 14, 2026)
  6. Sauna Marketplace: Penguin Cold Plunge Chiller and Filter Kit listing (read Nov 14, 2026)