Quick answer

The Finnmark SoulCold is the better plunge if you want to recline and want the most cooling power, and the SaunaLife S1 package is the better value if you sit upright and want to bring the chiller indoors for winter. On paper the SoulCold's built-in system has 4.45 kW of cooling against 2.81 kW for the S1's FDC-1A chiller, for 180 gallons against 124. The S1 package sets lower (32.5°F against 34°F), costs roughly three quarters as much, and splits into a 143 lb tub and a 103 lb chiller instead of one 460 lb unit. Both plug into a standard 120V, 15 amp outlet and both carry two years of residential coverage under their current warranties.

At a glance

SaunaLife

SaunaLife S1 Cold Plunge with FDC-1A Chiller (S1NC / S1BC Package)

Round, upright wood tub with a separate chiller

Type
Round wood-clad tub with separate chiller/heater
Price tier
Mid
Best for
Upright, neck-deep plunging on a patio, with a chiller you can carry indoors for winter

Choose the SaunaLife S1 if you plunge upright, want to spend less, and need a chiller you can bring indoors for winter.

Finnmark Designs

Finnmark SoulCold Hot & Cold Plunge

Stainless recliner with the chiller built in

Type
Stainless recline tub with built-in chiller/heater
Price tier
Premium
Best for
Reclining plungers who want more cooling power, a carbon filter stage and one tidy unit

Choose the Finnmark SoulCold if you want to recline in stainless steel with more cooling power and a frost-free spot to keep it.

These two plunges come from the same distributor family. SaunaLife and Finnmark Designs are both handled by Bathing Brands in Wheeling, Illinois, and the chiller in the S1 package, the Finnmark FDC-1A, is the older sibling of the system built into the SoulCold. The manuals share whole pages: the same 88 W pump, the same R410A refrigerant, the same 59 to 109°F ambient rating for cooling and the same ±5°F performance note.

What differs is everything you touch. The SaunaLife S1 is a round, upright tub: a gray fiberglass insert 34.4 inches across and 36 inches deep, wrapped in thermally modified wood with matching round steps. The S1NC (natural) and S1BC (black) packages pair it with the FDC-1A chiller/heater on hoses. The Finnmark SoulCold is a long recliner: a 304 stainless steel tub 48 inches long inside, with Canadian cedar skirting, backrest and slats, and the chiller/heater built into the cabinet. We read the S1 tub manual, both Finnmark manuals, both current warranties and our own catalog and support notes. Here is how they compare.

Key differences between SaunaLife S1 and Finnmark SoulCold

  • Lowest set temperature: SaunaLife S1 32.5 °F, Finnmark SoulCold 34 °F.
  • Cooling capacity: SaunaLife S1 2.8 kW, Finnmark SoulCold 4.5 kW.
  • Heating capacity: SaunaLife S1 3.4 kW, Finnmark SoulCold 4.4 kW.
  • Cooling per 100 gallons: SaunaLife S1 2.3 kW, Finnmark SoulCold 2.5 kW.
  • Water capacity: SaunaLife S1 124 gal, Finnmark SoulCold 180 gal.
  • Heaviest single piece, empty: SaunaLife S1 143 lb, Finnmark SoulCold 460 lb.
  • Best for: SaunaLife S1: Upright, neck-deep plunging on a patio, with a chiller you can carry indoors for winter. Finnmark SoulCold: Reclining plungers who want more cooling power, a carbon filter stage and one tidy unit.

SaunaLife S1 vs Finnmark SoulCold by the numbers

Head to head: the numbers that matter

SaunaLife S1Finnmark SoulCold

Lowest set temperature[2]

SaunaLife S132.5 °F Edge
Finnmark SoulCold34 °F

Lower is better · FDC-1A manual vs current SoulCold manual; both say not to set below 32°F

Cooling capacity[5]

SaunaLife S12.8 kW
Finnmark SoulCold4.5 kW Edge

Higher is better · Manufacturer ratings from each manual's parameter table

Heating capacity[5]

SaunaLife S13.4 kW
Finnmark SoulCold4.4 kW Edge

Higher is better · Both heat to 108°F

Cooling per 100 gallons[5]

SaunaLife S12.3 kW
Finnmark SoulCold2.5 kW Edge

Higher is better · Our calculation: rated cooling divided by water capacity

Water capacity[1]

SaunaLife S1124 gal
Finnmark SoulCold180 gal

S1 tub manual; SoulCold listing

Heaviest single piece, empty[1]

SaunaLife S1143 lb Edge
Finnmark SoulCold460 lb

Lower is better · S1 tub 143 lb plus a separate 103 lb chiller

Filled weight[7]

SaunaLife S11,180 lb Edge
Finnmark SoulCold1,650 lb

Lower is better · S1 figure is our estimate: 143 lb tub plus 124 gal of water; SoulCold is published

Tub footprint[1]

SaunaLife S115.4 sq ft Edge
Finnmark SoulCold19.4 sq ft

Lower is better · S1 with steps (48.1 x 46 in) before the chiller; SoulCold 79.8 x 35 in

Water temperature range[5]

SaunaLife S1Finnmark SoulCold

SaunaLife S132.5 to 108 °F
Finnmark SoulCold34 to 108 °F

32.5 °F108 °F

Rated air temperature for cooling[2]

SaunaLife S1Finnmark SoulCold

SaunaLife S159 to 109 °F
Finnmark SoulCold59 to 109 °F

59 °F109 °F

How cold do bathhouses actually run? (SaunaShare data)

Coldest tub at each of the 65 SaunaShare bathhouses that publish a plunge temperature, out of 403 listings with a cold plunge. Median: 45°F.

Below 40°F9 bathhouses
40 to 44°F15 bathhouses
45 to 49°F25 bathhouses
50°F and up16 bathhouses

Lowest published setting: SaunaLife S1 32.5°F, Finnmark SoulCold 34°F. Most bathhouses run warmer than either floor.

Our scorecard (1 to 5, from published specs and our support history)
CategorySaunaLife S1Finnmark SoulCold
Cooling powerThe SoulCold's system is rated 4.45 kW of cooling against 2.81 kW for the FDC-1A, with a compressor nearly twice as powerful on paper.3/54/5
Comfort and postureThe S1 gives a 36 inch deep upright soak; the SoulCold gives a 48 inch long, 28 inch deep recline. Pick the posture you like.4/54/5
Footprint and accessThe S1 tub sits in about 15.4 sq ft with steps and weighs 143 lb; the SoulCold is one 460 lb, 79.8 inch long piece.4/53/5
Winter resilienceBoth manuals say to move the chiller indoors in freezing weather; the S1's is a separate 103 lb unit, while the SoulCold's is built into the tub.4/52/5
Water careBoth run ozone, a mesh prefilter and a 5-micron cartridge; the SoulCold adds a carbon stage and an included insulated cover.3/54/5
Warranty claritySoulCold has its own two-year document dated July 31, 2026; the S1 package relies on SaunaLife's general warranty while the FDC-1A manual still prints one year.3/54/5
ValueThe S1 chiller package costs roughly three quarters of the SoulCold and can also be bought tub-only to pair with another chiller.5/53/5

Category ratings, not a total: which one wins depends on which rows matter to you.

SaunaLife S1 Cold Plunge with FDC-1A Chiller (S1NC / S1BC Package) vs Finnmark SoulCold Hot & Cold Plunge: full specifications

SpecSaunaLife S1 Cold Plunge with FDC-1A Chiller (S1NC / S1BC Package)Finnmark SoulCold Hot & Cold Plunge
Configuration[4]Round upright tub plus separate FDC-1A chiller/heater on hosesRectangular recline tub with built-in chiller/heater
Water temperature[2]32.5 to 108°F34 to 108°F
Cooling / heating capacity[5]2.81 kW / 3.38 kW4.45 kW / 4.36 kW
Compressor power (cooling)[5]0.560 kW0.992 kW
Water capacity[7]124 gal180 gal
Tub interior[7]34.4 in diameter x 36 in deep48 x 31 x 28 in deep
Exterior size[1]Tub 40 in diameter x 41.3 in; 48.1 x 46 x 47.8 in with steps; chiller 21.3 x 15.4 x 25 in79.8 x 35 x 30 in
Weight[7]Tub 143 lb; chiller 103 lb460 lb dry; 1,650 lb with water
Materials[4]Fiberglass insert, thermally modified wood surround, round steps304 stainless steel tub, Canadian cedar skirt, backrest and slats
Electrical[5]110 to 120V, 60Hz, 15A, NEMA 5-15P, 14 AWG circuit wiring110 to 120V, 60Hz, 15A, NEMA 5-15P, 14 AWG circuit wiring
Filtration[5]Mesh prefilter, 5-micron main filter, ozoneMesh prefilter, 5-micron main filter, carbon filter, ozone
Replacement filters[9]Finnmark 5 in pleated four-packFinnmark 5 in pleated four-pack plus SoulCold carbon four-pack
Chiller clearance[2]20 in all around; 60 in clear in front of the fan20 in on all sides of the chiller; avoid enclosed spaces
Base[1]Level, reinforced, at least 3 in above surrounding groundManual says over 1,000 lb; plan for the 1,650 lb filled weight plus occupant
Freezing weather[5]Drain the tub and leave the drain valve open; move the chiller indoorsMove the chiller indoors or to an insulated area; freeze damage voids the warranty
Cover[7]Optional S1 insulated coverInsulated marine-grade vinyl cover included
Controls[2]Touchscreen plus Wi-Fi app (iOS and Android)LCD touchscreen plus Wi-Fi app (iOS and Android)
Warranty[6]2 years on tub and chiller per SaunaLife (Rev 260915); FDC-1A manual says 1 year2 years residential (July 31, 2026); older manual says 1 year

Cooling: the same chiller family, two sizes

Read the two Finnmark manuals side by side and the family resemblance is obvious. The FDC-1A that ships with the S1 packages and the system built into the SoulCold share the pump, refrigerant, ozone generator, filter housing and ambient ratings. The difference is the compressor. The SoulCold's draws 0.992 kW and is rated for 4.45 kW of cooling. The FDC-1A draws 0.560 kW and is rated for 2.81 kW.

The SoulCold also has more water to cool, so the gap narrows when you divide by volume: about 2.47 kW per 100 gallons for the SoulCold against 2.27 kW for the S1. Neither manufacturer publishes a cooling rate in degrees per hour, so treat the SoulCold as somewhat stronger on paper, not twice as fast.

The lowest setting runs the other way. The FDC-1A lists 32.5 to 108°F. The current SoulCold manual lists 34 to 108°F, even though Finnmark's own SoulCold page still shows 32.5°F. Both manuals warn against setting below 32°F or above 105°F, and both say real water temperature can vary by ±5°F with heat, sun, a weak circuit, a clogged filter or water volume. Both rate cooling for air between 59 and 109°F and tell you to unplug and cover the unit in extreme heat over 95°F with direct sun.

How cold you should go is a separate question. See our cold plunge temperature guide and cold plunge dangers.

Posture and space: upright barrel or long recliner

This is the choice most buyers should make first. The S1 is a round tub, 34.4 inches across inside and 36 inches deep, so you sit upright with the water at your shoulders. Its outside is 40 inches across, and with the steps it fills about 48 x 46 inches. The chiller is a separate 21.3 x 15.4 x 25 inch box on hoses, and its manual wants 20 inches of space all around and 60 inches clear in front of the fan.

The SoulCold is 79.8 x 35 x 30 inches outside, with a tub 48 inches long, 31 inches wide and 28 inches deep. You lie back against a cedar backrest. Its manual asks for 20 inches of clearance on all sides of the chiller area and says to avoid enclosed spaces.

Weight follows shape. The S1 tub weighs 143 lb empty and holds 124 gallons, which works out to roughly 1,180 lb filled by our math. The SoulCold weighs 460 lb dry and 1,650 lb with water, before anyone gets in. Its manual says the support must handle over 1,000 lb, which is less than the tub's own filled weight, so plan your deck or slab for the larger number plus a person, and get a contractor to check any deck or balcony.

Winter: why a separate chiller matters

Both Finnmark manuals carry the same warranty line: damage from freezing voids the warranty, and the chiller should be moved to an inside location or a properly insulated area during freezing conditions.

With the S1 package, that is a chore you can do. The FDC-1A weighs 103 lb, has wheels and a carry handle, and comes off its hoses. The S1 tub manual says to drain the tub in winter after use and leave the drain valve open so it cannot freeze and crack. The FDC-1A manual adds that the chiller must be emptied of standing water before any storage longer than a month.

With the SoulCold, the chiller is part of a 460 lb cabinet. In practice that means installing it somewhere that stays above freezing, such as a garage, basement, pool house or a mild-climate patio, or planning a sheltered, insulated spot from day one.

Water care, filters and the cedar question

Both systems circulate through a mesh prefilter and a 5-micron main cartridge with ozone. The SoulCold adds a carbon cartridge, and its manual explains why: new cedar releases harmless tannins that can tint the water a light amber, and the carbon helps adsorb them. The SoulCold ships with two 5-micron filters and four carbon filters. Its manual says to inspect filters every 10 uses and replace the paper core every 30 days.

Filter shopping is simpler than it looks. Finnmark's current dealer data specifies the same 5 inch pleated four-pack for both the SoulCold and the FDC-1A. Only the SoulCold needs the separate carbon four-pack. An older listing that said the pleated pack also fit SaunaLife's AP-1 chiller (used on the larger S2) has been withdrawn, so do not assume it.

The S1's outer wood needs care too. Its manual recommends oiling the wooden walls and steps at least once a year with an exterior wood oil, and says not to clean the tub with chlorine-containing or abrasive cleaners. The SoulCold comes with an insulated marine-grade vinyl cover. For the S1, the matching insulated cover is a separate purchase, and we would not skip it.

Warranty and commercial use, read carefully

The SoulCold now has its own warranty document, dated July 31, 2026: two years from delivery, residential use only, original purchaser only, US and Canada only. It excludes commercial, institutional and non-residential installs, and it excludes labor, removal, reinstallation and shipping. The older SoulCold manual still prints a one-year warranty, so keep the newer document with your receipt.

Finnmark's public SoulCold page still says "Built For Commercial Use" and advertises 20-micron filtration and 1,650 watts. The current warranty says commercial installation voids coverage, and the current manual describes a 5-micron main filter and no single wattage figure. If you run a studio or gym, the SoulCold is not covered for you.

The S1 package is covered by SaunaLife's current warranty (revision 260915), which lists 2 years for plunge tubs and 2 years for water chillers, residential use only, with commercial use voiding it. The FDC-1A manual's own warranty section still says one year from purchase. Ask for the package warranty in writing when you order, and keep it.

Who should buy which

Choose the SaunaLife S1 package if you like sitting upright and deep, you want the lowest setting of the two, your winters freeze, or you want to spend less. Because the tub is also sold on its own, you can pair it with another chiller you already trust.

Choose the Finnmark SoulCold if you want to recline, you want the stronger compressor and the carbon stage, you like stainless steel inside and cedar outside, and you have a spot that stays above freezing for a 1,650 lb filled tub.

Both plug into a standard 15 amp outlet, which makes either one easier to install than the 20 amp tubs at the top of the market. Our team's first impression of the S1 prototype was that it felt solid and roomy, in line with SaunaLife's saunas. Still deciding on the habit itself? Start with what the evidence says about cold plunge benefits.

The verdict

Which one should you buy?

Choose SaunaLife S1 if

  • You want to sit upright with water at your shoulders
  • Your winters freeze and the plunge lives outside
  • Your delivery path or deck limits a single 460 lb piece

Choose Finnmark SoulCold if

  • You want to lie back in a long stainless tub
  • You want the most cooling power and a carbon filter stage
  • You want the cover included and one tidy unit with no hoses

Choose the SaunaLife S1 if you plunge upright, want to spend less, and need a chiller you can bring indoors for winter. Choose the Finnmark SoulCold if you want to recline in stainless steel with more cooling power and a frost-free spot to keep it.

FAQ

Is the SaunaLife S1 better than the Finnmark SoulCold?

The SaunaLife S1 package is the better value and the better choice for upright plunging and cold winters, because its FDC-1A chiller is a separate 103 lb unit you can bring indoors. The Finnmark SoulCold is better for reclining, with 4.45 kW of cooling against the S1's 2.81 kW and a carbon filter stage.

Which gets colder, the SaunaLife S1 or the Finnmark SoulCold?

The SaunaLife S1 package sets lower, to 32.5°F with its FDC-1A chiller, while the current Finnmark SoulCold manual lists 34°F. The SoulCold has the stronger compressor, rated 4.45 kW of cooling against 2.81 kW, but neither maker publishes a cooling rate in degrees per hour.

Do the SaunaLife S1 and Finnmark SoulCold use the same filters?

The SaunaLife S1's FDC-1A chiller and the Finnmark SoulCold both use the Finnmark 5 inch pleated four-pack, according to Finnmark's current dealer data. Only the Finnmark SoulCold also uses the separate SoulCold carbon filter four-pack.

What outlet do the SaunaLife S1 and Finnmark SoulCold need?

The SaunaLife S1's FDC-1A chiller and the Finnmark SoulCold each run on 110 to 120V, 60Hz, 15 amps through a NEMA 5-15P plug with a GFCI cord, with 14 AWG circuit wiring. Both manuals call for a code-compliant circuit installed by a licensed electrician.

Can the SaunaLife S1 and Finnmark SoulCold stay outside in winter?

Both manuals say freeze damage voids the warranty and the chiller should be moved indoors or to an insulated area in freezing weather. The SaunaLife S1's chiller is a separate 103 lb unit and its tub manual says to drain the tub for winter, while the Finnmark SoulCold's chiller is built into its 460 lb cabinet, so it needs a frost-free location.

Is the Finnmark SoulCold warranty one year or two years?

The Finnmark SoulCold has a two-year residential warranty under its July 31, 2026 warranty document, which replaces the one-year wording in the older manual. Commercial installation voids the SoulCold warranty, even though Finnmark's product page still says the plunge is built for commercial use.

Can I use a Finnmark SoulCold or SaunaLife S1 in a gym or studio?

Neither the Finnmark SoulCold nor the SaunaLife S1 is covered for commercial use: both current warranties are residential only and say commercial installation voids coverage. A studio or gym should buy a plunge sold with a commercial warranty.

Sources we checked

Specifications were read from these documents on November 14, 2026. Makers change models; check the current manual before you buy.

  1. SaunaLife Soak Series S1N / S1B tub installation manual (REV 1.0, Jan 2025)
  2. Finnmark Designs FDC-1A chiller installation and operation manual
  3. SaunaLife limited warranty (Rev 260915)
  4. Sauna Marketplace: SaunaLife S1 Cold Plunge, tub or chiller package
  5. Finnmark SoulCold installation and operation manual (v1.0)
  6. Bathing Brands limited warranty, Finnmark Designs SoulCold Plunge Tub (July 31, 2026)
  7. Sauna Marketplace: Finnmark SoulCold Hot & Cold Plunge
  8. Finnmark Designs SoulCold product page
  9. Sauna Marketplace: Finnmark 5 inch pleated filters, four-pack (fits SoulCold and FDC-1A)
  10. Sauna Marketplace: Finnmark SoulCold carbon filters, four-pack (FD-F20)