Quick answer

For most home buyers the Plunge All-In is the better pick over the Morozko Forge, because it holds 37°F on a dedicated 20 amp circuit, adds an optional 104°F hot mode and arrives ready to fill. The Morozko Forge wins if you want water at 32°F with a lid of real ice, a stainless steel tub, a 3-year parts and labor warranty, and an outdoor unit warrantied down to -10°F with the pump running. The All-In's warranty is voided by adding ice to the tub, which tells you how differently these two think about cold. Most bathhouses that publish their plunge temperatures run 45 to 50°F, so the All-In already goes colder than most people need.

At a glance

Plunge

Plunge All-In (Gen 2)

Plug-and-plunge acrylic tub with app control

Type
Chiller-integrated acrylic tub
Price tier
Premium
Best for
Daily plungers who want 37 to 45°F water with no setup and an optional hot mode

Choose the Plunge All-In if you want a fast, app-controlled 37°F tub with an optional hot mode for indoor or mild-climate use.

Morozko

Morozko Forge (New Morozko Forge)

Stainless lay-down tub that freezes its own ice

Type
Ice-making stainless ice bath
Price tier
Premium
Best for
Plungers who want real ice and an outdoor tub that keeps working in winter

Choose the Morozko Forge if you want real ice, a stainless tub and a 3-year warranty on an outdoor unit that runs through a hard winter.

The Plunge All-In and the Morozko Forge are two of the best-known premium home cold plunges in the US, and they solve the same problem in opposite ways. The All-In is an acrylic tub with a 0.75 HP chiller built into the cabinet, Wi-Fi app control and an optional heater. You fill it with a garden hose, plug it into a dedicated 20 amp circuit and set a number between 37 and 104°F.

The Morozko Forge is a stainless steel tub in a Line-X coated body, cooled by Morozko's own copper refrigeration system. Morozko calls it a freezer, not a chiller: its controller goes down to 32°F and the tub grows a layer of ice, which owners break up before they get in. The current product is the New Morozko Forge, hand-built to order in Phoenix. Morozko's FAQ says the original Forge is discontinued and sold only used, so make sure a listing is for the new one. People cross-shop these two because both are plug-in, no-plumbing tubs in the same broad price band. On paper, the choice comes down to how cold you want the water, where the tub lives, and how much maintenance and warranty fine print you are willing to accept.

Key differences between Plunge All-In and Morozko Forge

  • Lowest set temperature: Plunge All-In 37 °F, Morozko Forge 32 °F.
  • Water capacity: Plunge All-In 105 gal, Morozko Forge 80 gal.
  • Warranty length: Plunge All-In 1 year, Morozko Forge 3 years.
  • Circuit required: Plunge All-In 20 amps, Morozko Forge 15 amps.
  • Lowest outdoor air temperature before you must winterize: Plunge All-In 32 °F, Morozko Forge -10 °F.
  • Exterior height: Plunge All-In 28.8 in, Morozko Forge 26.4 in.
  • Best for: Plunge All-In: Daily plungers who want 37 to 45°F water with no setup and an optional hot mode. Morozko Forge: Plungers who want real ice and an outdoor tub that keeps working in winter.

Plunge All-In vs Morozko Forge by the numbers

Head to head: the numbers that matter

Plunge All-InMorozko Forge

Lowest set temperature[1]

Plunge All-In37 °F
Morozko Forge32 °F Edge

Lower is better · Morozko makes ice at setpoints as high as about 38°F, per its FAQ

Water capacity[8]

Plunge All-In105 gal
Morozko Forge80 gal

Morozko's FAQ figure for the Forge; the product page lists no volume

Warranty length[9]

Plunge All-In1 year
Morozko Forge3 years Edge

Higher is better · Morozko covers parts and labor; Plunge offers paid extended plans

Circuit required[3]

Plunge All-In20 amps
Morozko Forge15 amps Edge

Lower is better · Plunge requires a dedicated 20 A circuit; Morozko says a standard 15 A circuit, no dedicated line

Lowest outdoor air temperature before you must winterize[4]

Plunge All-In32 °F
Morozko Forge-10 °F Edge

Lower is better · Morozko's -10°F rating requires the filter pump to run continuously

Exterior height[7]

Plunge All-In28.8 in
Morozko Forge26.4 in

Step-over height matters for knees and backs

Return window[1]

Plunge All-In30 days Edge
Morozko Forge14 days

Higher is better · Plunge charges a 25% restocking fee once shipped; Morozko refunds less shipping

How cold do bathhouses actually run? (SaunaShare data)

Coldest tub at each of the 65 SaunaShare bathhouses that publish a plunge temperature, out of 403 listings with a cold plunge. Median: 45°F.

Below 40°F9 bathhouses
40 to 44°F15 bathhouses
45 to 49°F25 bathhouses
50°F and up16 bathhouses

Lowest published setting: Plunge All-In 37°F, Morozko Forge 32°F. Most bathhouses run warmer than either floor.

Our scorecard (1 to 5, from published specs and our support history)
CategoryPlunge All-InMorozko Forge
Cold performanceThe Forge sets down to 32°F and makes ice; the All-In bottoms out at 37°F.4/55/5
Ease of setup and useThe All-In is delivered in-home in most zones and runs from an app; the Forge is hand-built to order with a roughly 5-week wait and may need ice broken before each plunge.5/54/5
Winter and outdoor usePlunge requires draining and winterizing at freezing; Morozko is warrantied outdoors to -10°F with the pump running.2/55/5
Warranty and termsOne year with strict voiding rules versus three years of parts and labor, though Morozko's is non-transferable and non-relocatable.2/54/5
Maintenance loadPlunge requires a monthly filter change and a chemical protocol; Morozko runs chlorine-free with a filter good for about 100 plunges.3/54/5
VersatilityThe All-In can add a heater to 104°F; the Forge is cold only.5/52/5

Category ratings, not a total: which one wins depends on which rows matter to you.

Plunge All-In (Gen 2) vs Morozko Forge (New Morozko Forge): full specifications

SpecPlunge All-In (Gen 2)Morozko Forge (New Morozko Forge)
Current model[8]All-In Gen 2 (residential)New Morozko Forge (original Forge discontinued)
Cooling system[1]Built-in 0.75 HP chillerCopper refrigeration that makes ice (HP not published)
Lowest set temperature[7]37°F32°F, with ice
Hot option[1]Optional heater to 104°FNone, cold only
Water capacity[8]105 gal80 gal (FAQ)
Exterior size[7]76.75 x 31.5 x 28.75 in79 or 85 x 28.75 x 26.375 in
Tub[7]Fiberglass-reinforced acrylic, fits users up to 6 ft 9 inStainless steel, 60 or 66 in long
Weight[1]238 lb empty, 1,150 lb fullNot published for the Forge
Electrical[3]120V, dedicated 20 A circuit, GFCI cord, no extension cords110V NEMA 5-15 plug with inline GFCI, standard 15 A circuit, about 650 W
Sanitation[8]Ozone, filter, chlorine or non-chlorine chemical protocolOzone and microfiltration, chlorine-free
Filter interval[4]Change at least every 30 days (warranty condition)Clean or replace about every 100 plunges
Water changes[6]Every 6 months minimum; 1 to 3 months without Plunge chemicalsNo routine changes; FAQ suggests a drain every 6 to 12 months
App control[12]Wi-Fi Plunge app (staying connected is a warranty condition)Wi-Fi Meross controller on units built after February 2025
Cold weather[9]Drain and winterize at 32°FWarrantied outdoors to -10°F with pump running
Warranty[9]1 year, residential only3 years parts and labor, non-transferable
Returns[9]30 days, 25% restocking fee once shipped14 days, refund less shipping
Built[7]Assembled in California; in-stock units ship within 8 business daysHand-built to order in Phoenix, AZ; allow 5 weeks

Cold: a 37°F chiller vs a 32°F ice maker

The Plunge All-In Gen 2 uses a 0.75 HP chiller that Plunge says can hold 37°F in 120°F air, and it cools at 10 to 12°F per hour per the product page. That is fast for a home tub. At the stated rate, a fresh fill of 60°F tap water would reach 45°F in under two hours.

The Morozko Forge works like a chest freezer pointed at your bath. Its controller sets any temperature down to 32°F, and Morozko's FAQ says it makes ice at setpoints as high as about 38°F, with more ice the lower you go. The maintenance page tells owners to unplug for 12 to 24 hours if the ice gets thicker than 2 inches. Breaking the sheet before you get in is part of the ritual, and Morozko sells that as a feature. The trade is time: the FAQ says to plan on 24 to 48 hours to start cooling from a fresh fill, or jump-start it with 100 to 200 lb of ice.

Here is the part the spec sheets skip. You do not need 32°F water. Of the 39 public saunas and bathhouses on SaunaShare that publish their plunge temperature, most run 45 to 50°F and only 5 go below 40°F (SaunaShare listings, November 2026). If ice appeals to you, that is a fine reason to buy a Morozko. It is not a requirement for a good plunge. See cold plunge dangers before you chase the bottom of either dial.

The ice clause: what each warranty forbids

This is the most telling difference between the two. Plunge's All-In Residential warranty, revised November 13, 2026, lists adding ice to the tub as an action that voids the warranty. Morozko builds its whole product around ice in the tub.

The Plunge warranty has other voiding conditions worth reading before you buy:

  • Not connecting the Plunge to the Plunge app and keeping firmware current.
  • Not changing the filter at least every 30 days.
  • A power loss of more than 1 hour without fully draining the tub.
  • Keeping it at or below 32°F without following Plunge's winterization steps.
  • Commercial use of a residential unit.

Coverage is 1 year on the shell, plumbing, chiller, heater and controls. Plunge pays parts and labor for covered defects, but you may be charged repair travel mileage, and the insulating cover is excluded.

Morozko covers the Forge for 3 years, parts and labor, against manufacturing defects. It is warrantied for pure Epsom salt and Morozko Minerals, but not chloride salts or Dead Sea salt. The catch is that it is non-transferable and non-relocatable without Morozko's permission, which hurts resale and matters if you move. Morozko also warns not to stand the unit on end or tilt it during a move, because that can drain compressor oil.

Winter and outdoor use

If your tub lives outside in a cold climate, this section decides it. Plunge says the only guaranteed way to avoid freeze damage to an All-In is to bring it into a temperature-controlled space. Its setup guide says that if the air stays below 32°F for 12 hours, you must drain the tub, filter and chiller and fully winterize. The winterizing procedure uses a specific antifreeze, and Plunge warns that letting the chiller try to run while the pump primes can damage it without warranty coverage.

Morozko takes the opposite view. A separate warming circuit keeps the filter, pump and piping from freezing, and the Forge is warrantied for outdoor use down to -10°F when the filter pump runs continuously. Morozko's warranty page mentions a Winter Package for protection to -40°F. One maintenance page cites 10°F, not -10°F, for the heated filter line alone, so follow the product page and warranty and run the pump 24/7 in deep cold.

Safety: An outdoor plunge in winter needs a lid that locks, a GFCI you test monthly, and a weather-rated outlet with an in-use cover. Never plunge alone in ice water, and read the dangers page first.

Power and installation

Plunge's help center, updated November 14, 2026, says every All-In needs its own dedicated 20 amp, 120V circuit with nothing else on it, plugged in directly with the supplied GFCI cord. Extension cords are prohibited, and the setup guide says using one may deny a warranty claim. The All-In product page still says 15A circuit, and Plunge's older comparison page lists 120V/20 amps, so wire for 20 A. Budget for an electrician if your garage or patio circuit is shared.

Morozko's FAQ says its ice baths draw about 650 W and run on a standard 110V, 15 amp circuit with no dedicated circuit or extra wiring needed. The Forge uses a NEMA 5-15P cord with an inline GFCI, and the tub and water are electrically grounded through that cord. Morozko's site requirements call for a hard, flat surface, a hose and a drain within reach, and 2 inches of clearance around the mechanical area.

Plunge's All-In needs more breathing room: 16 inches at the chiller end, 12 inches at the front for the drain, and 4 inches on the sides. Plunge says those minimums keep the warranty active. It also says to place the tub at least 6 feet from other outlets and appliances.

Water care and daily upkeep

The All-In runs ozone plus a filter and a chemical protocol. Plunge's care guide asks for weekly skimming and water-line wiping, a filter change at least monthly, and a full water change every 6 months. Skip Plunge's recommended chemicals and the water change moves to every 1 to 3 months. Plunge says not to fill the All-In with well water unless you strip it with an ion exchange filter first, and it says the tub should run 24/7 because stagnant water is not sanitary for the system.

Morozko runs chlorine-free: ozone plus a microfilter, no stabilizers and no routine water changes, and you top it off with a hose. The filter needs cleaning or replacement about every 100 plunges, and the bottom inlet strainer needs regular inspection. Morozko says its tubs are built for hard and well water. Its FAQ is honest about the limit: ozone disinfects but does not remove body oils and lotion, so shower first or the water clouds.

Both are easier than a stock tank on bags of ice. The All-In has more scheduled tasks with warranty consequences. The Forge has fewer tasks, but one of them is a hammer.

Price, delivery and who each one is for

Both sit in the premium tier. At list price the Morozko Forge costs roughly a quarter more than the Plunge All-In, and Plunge's holiday discounting widens that gap. The All-In includes an insulated cover and free in-home delivery in most zones; in-stock units ship within 8 business days. The Forge is hand-built to order in Phoenix, so allow about 5 weeks.

Choose the All-In if you want water ready at 37 to 50°F every morning with app control, the option of a 104°F soak, and an indoor or mild-climate install. Choose the Forge if ice is part of why you plunge, if the tub will sit outdoors through a hard winter, or if a 3-year parts and labor warranty matters more to you than resale. If you are not sure you will plunge three times a week, start cheaper, and read our guide to what the evidence supports before you spend either amount.

The verdict

Which one should you buy?

Choose Plunge All-In if

  • You want water at 37 to 45°F every morning with no ice to break
  • You also want a hot soak up to 104°F
  • You want it delivered inside and running within two weeks

Choose Morozko Forge if

  • You want a real layer of ice and water at 32°F
  • The tub lives outdoors where winter drops well below freezing
  • You want the longest factory warranty

Choose the Plunge All-In if you want a fast, app-controlled 37°F tub with an optional hot mode for indoor or mild-climate use. Choose the Morozko Forge if you want real ice, a stainless tub and a 3-year warranty on an outdoor unit that runs through a hard winter.

FAQ

Is the Plunge All-In better than the Morozko Forge?

The Plunge All-In is the better choice for most home buyers because it holds 37°F, offers an optional 104°F heater and ships in-stock within 8 business days. The Morozko Forge is better for people who want water at 32°F with ice on top, or an outdoor tub warrantied to -10°F. Neither is better at producing a plunge in the 45 to 50°F range most bathhouses use.

How cold does the Morozko Forge get compared with the Plunge All-In?

The Morozko Forge controller sets down to 32°F and the tub makes ice, according to Morozko's product page and FAQ. The Plunge All-In Gen 2 is rated to 37°F. Plunge says its chiller cools 10 to 12°F per hour, while Morozko says to plan on 24 to 48 hours to start cooling from a fresh fill unless you add ice.

Can you put ice in a Plunge All-In?

No. Plunge's All-In Residential warranty, revised November 13, 2026, lists adding ice to the tub as an action that voids the warranty. If you want ice in your plunge, the Morozko Forge is designed to make its own.

What electrical circuit do the Plunge All-In and Morozko Forge need?

Plunge's help center says the All-In requires a dedicated 120V, 20 amp circuit with no extension cord. Morozko says the Forge draws about 650 W and runs on a standard 110V, 15 amp outlet with no dedicated circuit, using a NEMA 5-15P plug with an inline GFCI. Have an electrician confirm your circuit before delivery either way.

Can the Plunge All-In or the Morozko Forge stay outdoors in winter?

The Morozko Forge is warrantied outdoors down to -10°F as long as its filter pump runs continuously. Plunge says the All-In must be drained and winterized if the air stays below 32°F for 12 hours, and freeze damage is not covered. For a cold-climate outdoor install, the Forge is the safer bet on paper.

Which has the better warranty, Plunge or Morozko?

Morozko covers the Forge for 3 years of parts and labor, but the warranty is non-transferable and non-relocatable without Morozko's permission. Plunge covers the All-In for 1 year, and the warranty can be voided by skipping monthly filter changes, disconnecting the app, adding ice or a power loss of more than an hour without draining.

Is the Morozko Forge discontinued?

The original Morozko Forge is discontinued and Morozko says it is available only used. The current model is the New Morozko Forge, sold on morozkoforge.com in 60 or 66 inch tub lengths and two colors. Check that any listing you buy from is the new model.

Sources we checked

Specifications were read from these documents on November 14, 2026. Makers change models; check the current manual before you buy.

  1. Plunge All-In Gen 2 product page and specifications (plunge.com, read via en-ca locale, Nov 2026)
  2. Plunge Help Center: Manual and Setup Guide for the Residential Plunge All-In (updated Nov 14, 2026)
  3. Plunge Help Center: Electrical Requirements for Plunge Cold-Plunge Models (updated Nov 14, 2026)
  4. Plunge All-In Residential 1-Year Limited Warranty (last revised Nov 13, 2026)
  5. Plunge Help Center: Winterizing the All-In Residential
  6. Plunge Help Center: Caring for Your Residential Plunge All-In
  7. Morozko Forge product page (morozkoforge.com)
  8. Morozko ice bath FAQ (morozkoforge.com)
  9. Morozko Return Policy and Warranty
  10. Morozko Ice Bath Technology page
  11. Morozko Temperature and Ice maintenance page
  12. Morozko Owner's Ice Bath Manual page
  13. Plunge cold plunge lineup page (plunge.com, Nov 2026)
  14. Plunge tech specs comparison page (older All-In figures)