Quick answer
The Plunge All-In Gen 2 is the better buy for most cold plungers, and the KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath is better for a design-led home that wants hot and cold baths year-round with the fewest winter rules. On paper the All-In gets colder (37°F against 39°F), weighs 238 lb empty against 605 lb, and costs a little over half as much at list. The Kohler answers with heating to 104°F as standard, a two-year warranty against Plunge's one year, and a manual that says it is designed to run all year and heats itself when the air drops below 40°F. Plunge's warranty is void if the tub freezes, loses power for more than an hour without being drained, or is not kept connected to its app.
Kohler
KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath (K-35848)
Furniture-grade hot and cold bath, 39 to 104°F
- Type
- Freestanding hot and cold bath with built-in heat pump
- Price tier
- Luxury
- Best for
- Design-led homes that want hot and cold in one bath, used year-round with little winter fuss
Choose the Kohler Ice Bath if you want a year-round hot and cold bath that looks like furniture and carries a two-year warranty.
Plunge
Colder, lighter, app-first plug-and-plunge tub
- Type
- Chiller-integrated acrylic tub
- Price tier
- Premium
- Best for
- Daily cold plungers who want 37°F, app control and a lighter tub at a lower price
Choose the Plunge All-In if cold is the goal and you want 37°F, app control and a lighter tub for far less money.
These are the two names that come up when someone wants a finished, plug-in cold plunge for a nice house rather than a stock tank and a chiller. The KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath (model K-35848) was designed with Remedy Place, the recovery club, and is built like a piece of bathroom furniture: an Avonite Flex bath inside high pressure laminate panels, a cushioned headrest, grab points, storage for towels and filters, and a breath-pacing light on a timer. It heats and cools between 39 and 104°F as standard.
The Plunge All-In is Plunge's self-contained tub, now in its second generation (launched September 2025). The chiller, pump, ozone and filtration live inside the shell, it cools to 37°F, and almost everything runs through the Plunge app. A heater that takes it to 104°F is an add-on. One of our shoppers put Plunge's reach plainly on a call: they see its tubs "everywhere" in local contrast therapy studios. Kohler is the newer, pricier entrant from a plumbing brand. We read both spec sheets, both installation guides, both owner's manuals and both warranties end to end. Here is what they say.
Key differences between Kohler Ice Bath and Plunge All-In
- Lowest set temperature: Kohler Ice Bath 39 °F, Plunge All-In 37 °F.
- Highest set temperature: Kohler Ice Bath 104 °F, Plunge All-In 104 °F.
- Water capacity: Kohler Ice Bath 85 gal, Plunge All-In 105 gal.
- Empty weight: Kohler Ice Bath 605 lb, Plunge All-In 238 lb.
- Exterior footprint: Kohler Ice Bath 22.8 sq ft, Plunge All-In 16.8 sq ft.
- Power cord length: Kohler Ice Bath 12 ft, Plunge All-In 7 ft.
- Best for: Kohler Ice Bath: Design-led homes that want hot and cold in one bath, used year-round with little winter fuss. Plunge All-In: Daily cold plungers who want 37°F, app control and a lighter tub at a lower price.
Kohler Ice Bath vs Plunge All-In by the numbers
Kohler Ice BathPlunge All-In
Lowest set temperature[1]
Lower is better · Kohler spec sheet; Plunge product page says 37°F
Highest set temperature[6]
Standard on the Kohler; the All-In needs its optional heater
Water capacity[11]
Plunge figure is approximate, from its tech specs page
Empty weight[1]
Lower is better · Kohler recommends at least three people to carry it
Exterior footprint[1]
Lower is better · Calculated from 79-1/8 x 41-7/16 in and 76-3/4 x 31-1/2 in
Power cord length[3]
Higher is better · Neither should run on an extension cord
Longest gap between water changes[10]
Higher is better · Plunge's 6 months assumes its chemical protocol; 1 to 3 months without
Factory warranty[4]
Higher is better · Both residential only; commercial use voids both
Kohler Ice BathPlunge All-In
37 °F104 °F
Coldest tub at each of the 65 SaunaShare bathhouses that publish a plunge temperature, out of 403 listings with a cold plunge. Median: 45°F.
Lowest published setting: Kohler Ice Bath 39°F, Plunge All-In 37°F. Most bathhouses run warmer than either floor.
| Category | Kohler Ice Bath | Plunge All-In |
|---|---|---|
| Cold performanceThe All-In sets to 37°F and Plunge publishes up to 12°F per hour of cooling; Kohler stops at 39°F and publishes no cooling rate. | 3/5 | 5/5 |
| Hot soakBoth reach 104°F, but heat is standard on the Kohler and an add-on for the All-In. | 5/5 | 4/5 |
| Cold-climate ownershipKohler auto-heats below 40°F air and is designed for year-round use; Plunge says drain and winterize after 12 hours below 32°F, and freeze damage is not covered. | 5/5 | 2/5 |
| WarrantyTwo years from Kohler against one from Plunge, whose terms add voiding conditions such as power loss over an hour, added ice and lost app connection. | 4/5 | 2/5 |
| App and smart controlThe Plunge app sets temperature remotely and sends filter reminders; Kohler's spec describes its app as educational videos and training content. | 2/5 | 5/5 |
| Design and comfortKohler adds a cushioned headrest, grab points, built-in storage and a breath light; the All-In is a clean acrylic tub that fits users up to 6 ft 9 in. | 5/5 | 4/5 |
| Delivery and placement605 lb and 22.8 sq ft for the Kohler against 238 lb and 16.8 sq ft, and Plunge includes in-home first-floor delivery in most of its service area. | 2/5 | 4/5 |
Category ratings, not a total: which one wins depends on which rows matter to you.
KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath (K-35848) vs Plunge All-In (Gen 2): full specifications
| Spec | KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath (K-35848) | Plunge All-In (Gen 2) |
|---|---|---|
| Current model[1] | K-35848 (Burnt Umber), spec sheet regenerated Oct 2026 | All-In Gen 2, residential (launched Sept 2025) |
| Water temperature[6] | 39 to 104°F, heating standard | Down to 37°F; 104°F with optional heater |
| Cooling rate[6] | Not published | Up to 12°F per hour |
| Water capacity[11] | 85 gal | About 105 gal |
| Water depth[1] | 18 in | Not published |
| Exterior size[1] | 79-1/8 x 41-7/16 x 27-1/8 in | 76-3/4 x 31-1/2 x 28-3/4 in |
| Bathing area[6] | 47-1/8 x 24-13/16 in at the top, 44-1/8 x 23 in at the bottom | 65 x 30 in tub; fits users up to 6 ft 9 in |
| Weight[1] | 605 lb empty; full weight not published (59.9 lb/sq ft minimum floor load) | 238 lb empty, 1,150 lb full |
| Materials[1] | Avonite Flex bath, high pressure laminate panels | Fiberglass reinforced acrylic |
| Electrical[8] | 120V, 20A, 60Hz dedicated circuit, Class A GFCI; 12 ft cord | 120V dedicated 20A circuit, supplied GFCI cord (7 ft); no extension cords |
| Sanitation[1] | UV light plus 24/7 filtration; 30-micron cartridge | Ozone plus filtration (20-micron per Plunge tech specs) and a chemical protocol |
| Filter changes[9] | Monthly or as needed | At least every 30 days (a warranty condition) |
| Water changes[10] | Every 1 to 2 months | Every 6 months with Plunge chemicals; 1 to 3 months without |
| Freezing weather[7] | Auto-heats water when air is below 40°F; designed for year-round use | Drain and winterize after 12 hours below 32°F; freeze damage not covered |
| Plumbing[1] | Optional home water line (vacuum breaker 6 in above rim), built-in filler, optional floor drain | No plumbing; fill by garden hose through included carbon filter |
| App[7] | KOHLER Konnect app with educational videos and training content | Plunge app: remote temperature, filter reminders, firmware updates |
| Safety listing[1] | UL 1563 | Not published on the product page |
| Warranty[9] | 2-year limited, residential, US and Canada | 1-year limited, residential, 50 states and DC |
Cold and hot: what each one promises on paper
The Plunge All-In sets down to 37°F. The Kohler sets down to 39°F. Two degrees will not change your morning, but the published cooling rate might. Plunge lists cooling of up to 12°F per hour and says the Gen 2 system cools 31% faster than the first generation using a variable-speed fan and pump. Kohler publishes no cooling rate, no compressor size and no wattage. The homeowners guide only says the pump can take up to 3 minutes to switch between cooling and heating, and that air above 104°F can push the water above your target.
Heat is where the Kohler pulls ahead. It reaches 104°F out of the box, so the same bath is a cold plunge before a workout and a hot soak after dinner. The All-In also reaches 104°F, but only with Plunge's optional heater, which you choose at checkout.
Neither tub needs to run at its floor to be useful. Most people plunge well above 37°F, and how cold is safe depends on you, not the tub. Read our cold plunge temperature guide and cold plunge dangers before you chase the bottom of either dial.
Size, comfort and delivery day
The Kohler is the bigger object and the smaller bath. Its exterior is 79-1/8 x 41-7/16 inches, about 22.8 sq ft of floor, yet it holds 85 gallons at an 18-inch water depth. Kohler's spec sheet measures the basin at 47-1/8 x 24-13/16 inches across the top. The rest of the cabinet carries the heat pump, storage and a wide rim with grab points. The All-In is 76-3/4 x 31-1/2 inches, about 16.8 sq ft, with a 65 x 30 inch tub that Plunge says fits users up to 6 ft 9 in, and holds about 105 gallons.
Comfort details favor the Kohler: a cushioned waterproof headrest, a 6-degree lumbar angle on the drawing, grab points for getting in and out, and storage for towels and spare filters. If you are tall, sit in a Kohler before you buy, because Kohler publishes no maximum user height.
Then there is the move. The Kohler weighs 605 lb empty, and its installation guide recommends at least three people to carry it and warns against lifting by the outer panels. The All-In weighs 238 lb, and Plunge includes in-home delivery to the first floor for most addresses within about 35 miles of a major airport hub.
Winter, power cuts and the warranty fine print
This is the biggest difference between the two, and neither brand puts it on the front page.
Kohler's homeowners guide says the bath is designed to be used throughout the year. If the air drops below 40°F, it automatically heats the water to stop it freezing. Kohler does not recommend winterizing or long storage, and gives a drain-down procedure only for when you must.
Plunge's residential setup guide says that if the air is below 32°F for 12 hours, you must drain the tub, filter and chiller and fully winterize it. Its one-year warranty is void if the tub sits in sub-freezing weather without that protocol, if it loses power for more than one hour and is not fully drained, if water is left stagnant, if you add ice, if you skip a filter change for more than 30 days, or if it is not connected to the Plunge app with current firmware.
Kohler's two-year warranty has its own conditions. Commercial installation voids it, and so do cleaners with chlorine bleach, ammonia, alcohol, strong alkaline solutions or abrasives. Kohler also does not pay for removal, installation or labor. Plunge pays for parts and labor on covered repairs but charges the owner for removal and reinstallation if the tub goes to a repair facility, and may charge travel mileage.
Water care and daily ownership
The two clean water in different ways. The Kohler runs UV sanitation and filtration around the clock with a 30-micron cartridge you replace monthly or as needed, plus a UV bulb you clean every 6 months. Kohler tells owners to keep total alkalinity and pH balanced and to replace the water every 1 to 2 months.
The All-In uses ozone plus filtration, and Plunge says the Gen 2 pump turns over the entire water volume every 15 minutes. Its care guide asks for weekly skimming, a filter change at least monthly, and a full water change every 6 months if you use Plunge's maintenance chemicals, or every 1 to 3 months if you do not. Plunge also says not to fill with untreated well water.
Day to day, the All-In is the more connected tub. The Plunge app sets temperature remotely, tracks sessions and reminds you about filters. Kohler's controls sit on the bath: on and off, temperature, heating or cooling status, exterior light brightness, and a timer that starts a breath-pacing light. Kohler's spec describes its app as educational videos and training content.
Install: outlet, water line and drain
Both need a dedicated 120V, 20 amp circuit with GFCI protection. Plunge's current setup guide and electrical article say 20 amps for the All-In, and that an extension cord can cost you warranty coverage. Its product page still lists 15 amps, so plan on 20.
- Cord reach: the Kohler has a 12 ft cord. The All-In has about 7 ft, and Plunge wants the tub at least 6 ft from outlets and appliances, so plan the outlet carefully.
- Water: the Kohler can connect to your home water supply with a vacuum breaker 6 inches above the rim, has a built-in bath filler, and can use an optional floor drain. The All-In needs no plumbing and fills from a garden hose through its carbon filter.
- Condensation: Kohler supplies a hose to route heat pump condensation to a floor drain. Plunge says it is not liable for condensation damage and requires a waterproof surface.
- Clearance: Kohler's roughing-in drawing shows minimum clearances of 24 to 48 inches around the bath. Plunge asks for 16 inches at the equipment end, 12 inches at the front and 4 inches on the sides.
Safety: both manufacturers require GFCI protection. Test the GFCI before each use, and have an electrician confirm the circuit is dedicated before delivery day.
Who should buy which
At list price the Kohler costs nearly twice what the All-In does, and more than that when Plunge runs a sale. That money buys a bath that heats as standard, looks like furniture, carries a two-year warranty and is designed to stay filled through winter. It does not buy colder water or a published cooling rate.
Choose the Plunge All-In if you plunge most days, care about the coldest setting, want app control, and live where you can keep it powered and above freezing or will drain it when you cannot. Choose the Kohler if the bath sits in a finished room or a design-led backyard, you want hot and cold from one tub, and you value a longer warranty and fewer winter rules over the last two degrees.
Remedy Place, the club that co-designed the Kohler, runs its own locations, and you can find them on SaunaShare. Trying a session there is a good way to decide whether the Kohler's posture suits you. Still weighing the habit itself? Start with what the evidence says about cold plunge benefits.
The verdict
Choose Kohler Ice Bath if
- You want a hot soak to 104°F without buying an add-on
- Your winters drop below freezing and you do not want to drain the tub
- The bath has to look like part of a finished room
Choose Plunge All-In if
- You want the coldest water and a published cooling rate
- You want to set the temperature from your phone
- Your delivery path has stairs, tight turns or a narrow door
Choose the Kohler Ice Bath if you want a year-round hot and cold bath that looks like furniture and carries a two-year warranty. Choose the Plunge All-In if cold is the goal and you want 37°F, app control and a lighter tub for far less money.
FAQ
Is the Kohler Ice Bath better than the Plunge All-In?
The Plunge All-In is better for most cold plungers because it sets to 37°F, publishes cooling of up to 12°F per hour, weighs 238 lb and costs a little over half as much at list. The KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath is better for buyers who want heating to 104°F as standard, a two-year warranty and a bath designed to stay in use through winter.
Which gets colder, the Kohler Ice Bath or the Plunge All-In?
The Plunge All-In gets colder, with a 37°F lowest setting against 39°F for the KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath. Plunge also publishes a cooling rate of up to 12°F per hour, while Kohler publishes no cooling rate.
Can the Kohler Ice Bath and the Plunge All-In stay outside in winter?
The KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath is designed for year-round use and automatically heats its water when the air falls below 40°F. Plunge says the All-In must be drained and winterized if the air stays below 32°F for 12 hours, and its warranty does not cover freeze damage.
What electrical circuit do the Kohler Ice Bath and Plunge All-In need?
Both need a dedicated 120V, 20 amp circuit with GFCI protection. The Kohler's cord is 12 ft long and the Plunge All-In's is about 7 ft, and Plunge says using an extension cord can void its warranty.
How long is the warranty on the Kohler Ice Bath vs the Plunge All-In?
The KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath has a two-year limited residential warranty in the US and Canada. The Plunge All-In has a one-year limited residential warranty that is voided by conditions including freezing, more than one hour without power while filled, adding ice, and not keeping the tub connected to the Plunge app.
Does the Plunge All-In heat like the Kohler Ice Bath?
The Plunge All-In can heat to 104°F only with Plunge's optional heater, chosen at purchase. The KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath heats to 104°F as standard, so the same bath works as a cold plunge and a hot soak.
How often do you change the water in the Kohler Ice Bath and the Plunge All-In?
Kohler tells owners to replace the Ice Bath's water every 1 to 2 months. Plunge says the All-In's water lasts up to 6 months with its maintenance chemicals, or 1 to 3 months without them.
Sources we checked
Specifications were read from these documents on November 14, 2026. Makers change models; check the current manual before you buy.
- KOHLER K-35848 Ice Bath US/Canada specification sheet (Oct 2026; same content as the Oct 9, 2026 revision)
- KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath homeowners guide (1610180-5-B)
- KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath outdoor installation guide (1637969-2-A)
- KOHLER x Remedy Place Ice Bath two-year limited warranty (1610180-12-A)
- Sauna Marketplace: Kohler x Remedy Place Ice Bath listing
- Plunge All-In Gen 2 product page, specs and FAQ (read Nov 14, 2026)
- Plunge Help Center: Manual and Setup Guide for the Residential Plunge All-In (updated Nov 14, 2026)
- Plunge Help Center: Electrical Requirements for Plunge Cold-Plunge Models (updated Nov 14, 2026)
- Plunge All-In Residential 1-Year Limited Warranty (updated Nov 13, 2026)
- Plunge Help Center: Caring for Your Residential Plunge All-In
- Plunge tech specs comparison page (capacity and filter figures)
- Plunge blog: How the Gen 2 Plunge chilling system works
