Quick answer
For most home buyers the Plunge All-In is the better pick over the Renu Therapy Cold Stoic 3.0, because its 0.75 HP chiller is rated to cool 10 to 12°F per hour against Renu's 1.5 to 3°F, it holds 105 gallons, and it is delivered inside your home in most zones. The Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 wins if you want the heater included, an upright seated plunge with a breath deck, and a 5-year warranty on everything but the chiller. Both reach 37°F and 104°F, and both chillers carry only 1 year of coverage. Renu also costs more at list.
Renu Therapy
Upright California-built tub with heater included
- Type
- Chiller-integrated hot and cold tub
- Price tier
- Premium
- Best for
- Buyers who want hot and cold included, an upright seated plunge and a 5-year body warranty
Choose the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 if you want hot and cold included, an upright seated plunge and a 5-year body warranty.
Plunge
Fast-cooling lay-back tub with app control
- Type
- Chiller-integrated acrylic tub
- Price tier
- Premium
- Best for
- Daily plungers who want the fastest cooling and in-home delivery
Choose the Plunge All-In if you want the fastest cooling on paper, a roomy lay-back tub and in-home delivery.
The Renu Therapy Cold Stoic 3.0 and the Plunge All-In Gen 2 are two of the most common premium plug-in tubs US buyers compare. Both put a chiller, pump, ozone and filters inside the cabinet, both plug into a 120V outlet, both run from an app, and both reach 37°F cold and 104°F hot. That is why the decision is hard: the headline numbers match.
The differences are in the details. The Cold Stoic 3.0 is Renu's flagship, handcrafted in Southern California, with a 0.5 HP chiller, a 1 kW heater included, and an upright tub 31 inches deep that you sit in with your knees bent. Renu also sells the newer, smaller Vero, launched in November 2025 with a 0.8 HP chiller and a 37 to 100°F range; we cover it briefly below. The All-In is Plunge's top home model, now in its second generation, with a 0.75 HP chiller, an optional heater and a long lay-back tub that Plunge says fits users up to 6 feet 9 inches. On paper, the gap is cooling speed, warranty structure and how the tub reaches your patio.
Key differences between Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 and Plunge All-In
- Lowest set temperature: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 37 °F, Plunge All-In 37 °F.
- Chiller size: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 0.5 HP, Plunge All-In 0.8 HP.
- Cooling rate, top of published range: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 3 °F per hour, Plunge All-In 12 °F per hour.
- Water capacity: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 95 gal, Plunge All-In 105 gal.
- Warranty on tub and components: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 5 years, Plunge All-In 1 year.
- Chiller warranty: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 1 year, Plunge All-In 1 year.
- Best for: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0: Buyers who want hot and cold included, an upright seated plunge and a 5-year body warranty. Plunge All-In: Daily plungers who want the fastest cooling and in-home delivery.
Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 vs Plunge All-In by the numbers
Renu Cold Stoic 3.0Plunge All-In
Lowest set temperature[2]
Lower is better · Both makers rate their chillers to 37°F
Chiller size[7]
Higher is better · Plunge's older spec page lists 1 HP; the Gen 2 product page says 0.75 HP
Cooling rate, top of published range[3]
Higher is better · Renu's manual says 1.5 to 3°F per hour; Plunge says 10 to 12°F per hour
Water capacity[2]
Renu fills to 91 to 104 gal depending on level; 95 gal is its rated fill
Warranty on tub and components[5]
Higher is better · Excludes the chiller on the Renu
Chiller warranty[5]
Higher is better · Renu sells an extension to 5 years total if bought within 364 days of shipment
Return window[6]
Higher is better · Renu: 5% fee plus shipping, sale items final. Plunge: 25% fee once shipped
Circuit[9]
Lower is better · Renu recommends a dedicated 15 A circuit; Plunge requires a dedicated 20 A circuit
Renu Cold Stoic 3.0Plunge All-In
37 °F104 °F
Coldest tub at each of the 65 SaunaShare bathhouses that publish a plunge temperature, out of 403 listings with a cold plunge. Median: 45°F.
Lowest published setting: Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 37°F, Plunge All-In 37°F. Most bathhouses run warmer than either floor.
| Category | Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 | Plunge All-In |
|---|---|---|
| Cooling powerA 0.5 HP chiller rated 1.5 to 3°F per hour versus 0.75 HP rated 10 to 12°F per hour. | 3/5 | 5/5 |
| Hot and coldRenu includes a 1 kW heater; Plunge's heater to 104°F is an add-on option. | 5/5 | 4/5 |
| Warranty5 years on the Renu body versus 1 year on the whole All-In, though Renu expects owners to do most repairs and pay shipping. | 4/5 | 2/5 |
| Delivery and setupRenu delivers curbside and you move a 365 lb tank off the pallet; Plunge offers free in-home delivery in most zones. | 3/5 | 5/5 |
| Maintenance loadRenu's filters run 2 to 4 weeks and 6 to 10 weeks; Plunge requires a monthly filter change as a warranty condition. | 4/5 | 3/5 |
| Buyer termsRenu allows 45 days with a 5% restocking fee; Plunge allows 30 days with a 25% fee once shipped. | 4/5 | 3/5 |
Category ratings, not a total: which one wins depends on which rows matter to you.
Renu Therapy Cold Stoic 3.0 vs Plunge All-In (Gen 2): full specifications
| Spec | Renu Therapy Cold Stoic 3.0 | Plunge All-In (Gen 2) |
|---|---|---|
| Current model[1] | Cold Stoic 3.0 (flagship; Vero is the newer compact model) | All-In Gen 2 (residential) |
| Chiller[2] | 0.5 HP | 0.75 HP |
| Heater[7] | 1 kW, included | Optional, heats to 104°F |
| Temperature range[2] | 37 to 104°F | 37°F cold; to 104°F with heater |
| Cooling rate[3] | 1.5 to 3°F per hour | 10 to 12°F per hour |
| Heating rate[3] | 4 to 6°F per hour | 4 to 5°F per hour |
| Exterior size[2] | 70 x 33 x 35 in | 76.75 x 31.5 x 28.75 in |
| Tub shape[2] | Upright, 40 x 25 x 31 in deep | Lay-back, fits users up to 6 ft 9 in |
| Water capacity[1] | 95 gal (134 gal total volume) | 105 gal |
| Weight[2] | 365 lb dry, about 1,155 lb filled | 238 lb empty, 1,150 lb full |
| Electrical[9] | 120V 15 A, dedicated circuit recommended, GFCI plug, 12 ft cord | 120V, dedicated 20 A circuit required, 7 ft GFCI cord, no extension cords |
| Published power use[2] | 518 W peak cooling; 130 W average over 24 h at 40°F | Not published |
| Noise[2] | 58 dB at about 3 ft from the large vent | Not published |
| Insulation and cover[1] | 4 in perimeter foam; insulated spa cover is an add-on | Insulated spa cover included |
| Filtration and sanitation[3] | Dual-stage filters plus ozone | Filter plus ozone and a chlorine or non-chlorine chemical protocol |
| Clearance[4] | 27 in at large vent, 15 in at small vent, 1 to 2 in cord side | 16 in at chiller end, 12 in front, 4 in sides |
| Warranty[5] | 5 years, chiller 1 year (extendable to 5) | 1 year, residential only |
| Delivery[1] | Free curbside; ships in 3 to 5 weeks | Free in-home delivery in most zones; in-stock ships within 8 business days |
Cooling: same 37°F floor, very different speed
Both tubs are rated to 37°F, so the low number on the dial is a tie. How fast they get there is not. Renu's Cold Stoic 3.0 manual says the water drops 1.5 to 3°F per hour in cooling mode with its 0.5 HP chiller. Plunge says the All-In Gen 2's 0.75 HP chiller cools 10 to 12°F per hour and can hold 37°F in 120°F air.
Those are each maker's own figures, measured their own way, so treat the gap as directional. It still matters in daily use. Recovery speed decides whether the water is back to temperature when a second person plunges, after you top off with warm hose water, or after a hot afternoon on a patio. On paper, the All-In recovers several times faster.
Renu does publish something Plunge does not: power use. The cut sheet lists 518 W peak while cooling and a 24-hour average of 130 W holding 40°F, about 3.1 kWh a day. Plunge says Gen 2 uses 50% less energy than before but gives no watt figure.
Hot water: included vs optional, and our caution
The Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 ships with a 1 kW heater and a 104°F setting, with a shortcut button on the touchscreen. Renu's manual says heating runs 4 to 6°F per hour, and the cut sheet lists 1,013 W peak and a 260 W 24-hour average holding 100°F. The Plunge All-In offers a heater to 104°F as an option at checkout and rates it at 4 to 5°F per hour. Plunge's care protocol is written for cold water, so ask Plunge how the chemistry changes if you plan to run it hot often.
If you want a warm soak, both will do it, slowly. Going from 40 to 100°F takes at least 10 hours at either maker's published rate, so this is not a sauna-and-plunge contrast circuit in one tub. Pick one temperature for the season.
Warranty fine print, side by side
Renu's headline is a 5-year limited warranty, and for plastic-body tubs like the Cold Stoic 3.0 it does cover all components for 5 years, except the water chiller, which is covered for 1 year. You can buy a chiller extension to 5 years total, but only within 364 days of shipment. Read the service model too: Renu's warranty says most repairs and component replacements are performed by the customer. If you cannot do it, Renu pays an approved technician for up to 2 hours at a capped hourly rate, and the customer pays shipping costs. Freezing, poor water chemistry, neglected filters and low flow are excluded, and coverage stays with the original purchaser.
Plunge covers the All-In for 1 year on everything: shell, plumbing, chiller, heater, controls and the purification system, with parts and labor paid for covered defects. In exchange, the warranty is voided if you skip a filter change for more than 30 days, disconnect from the Plunge app, add ice to the tub, let the tub sit through a power loss longer than 1 hour without draining it, or leave it below 32°F without winterizing.
On paper, Renu protects the tub longer and Plunge protects the service experience better in year one. The chiller, the part most likely to fail, has 1 year of coverage on both unless you pay for more.
Size, shape and getting it in the door
These tubs feel different. The Cold Stoic 3.0's water area is 40 inches long, 25 inches wide and 31 inches deep, so you sit upright with your knees bent. The composite breath deck around it is built for breathwork before you get in. The All-In is a long lay-back tub, 76.75 inches outside, and Plunge says it fits users up to 6 feet 9 inches. Tall plungers who want to stretch out will prefer the All-In. People who like a compact, upright sit will prefer the Renu.
Delivery is the bigger difference. Renu ships free curbside, ready in 3 to 5 weeks, and the customer moves the 365 lb tank off the pallet to its final spot. Plunge offers free in-home delivery to the first level in most zones, with in-stock units shipping within 8 business days, but it does not include setup or power. Renu's Cold Stoic 3.0 page showed Sold Out on the day we checked, so confirm the ship date before you plan around it.
Power, clearance and upkeep
Renu's spec sheet calls for a standard 120V, 15 amp, 3-prong outlet, with a dedicated circuit recommended, a GFCI plug and a 12 foot cord. Plunge's help center, updated November 14, 2026, requires a dedicated 120V, 20 amp circuit for every All-In and prohibits extension cords. The All-In product page still says 15A, so wire for Plunge's 20 A requirement to be safe.
Clearance differs too. Renu wants 27 inches at the large vent so you can reach the mechanics bay, and 15 inches at the small vent. Plunge wants 16 inches at the chiller end, 12 inches at the front and 4 inches on the sides, and says those minimums keep the warranty active.
For upkeep, Renu replaces its in-tank pre-filter every 2 to 4 weeks, cleans the XL filter every 6 to 10 weeks and changes the water every 3 to 6 months. Plunge asks for weekly skimming, a monthly filter change and a water change at least every 6 months, or every 1 to 3 months if you skip its recommended chemicals. Plunge also says not to fill the All-In with untreated well water.
What about the Renu Vero?
Renu launched the Vero in November 2025 as a smaller, upright, cold-first tub. Its press release lists a 0.8 HP chiller, cooling to 37°F, an optional heater to 100°F, Renu's app, a 5-inch touchscreen and a 5-year limited warranty, and says it fits through a standard 34-inch doorway. Renu's spec page lists 95 gallons and a 12 amp draw, and it is the one Renu model that needs light setup. If the Cold Stoic 3.0's speed worries you but you like Renu's warranty and upright sit, the Vero is worth a look. We have not seen independent data on its cooling rate.
The verdict
Choose Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 if
- You will use the hot side and want the heater included
- You want the longest coverage on the tub itself
- You like a compact, upright seat with a breath deck
Choose Plunge All-In if
- You want the water back to temperature fast between plunges
- You are tall and want to lie back fully
- You cannot move a 365 lb tank off a pallet yourself
Choose the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 if you want hot and cold included, an upright seated plunge and a 5-year body warranty. Choose the Plunge All-In if you want the fastest cooling on paper, a roomy lay-back tub and in-home delivery.
FAQ
Is the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 better than the Plunge All-In?
For most buyers the Plunge All-In is better because its 0.75 HP chiller is rated to cool 10 to 12°F per hour versus 1.5 to 3°F per hour for the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0. The Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 is better if you want the heater included, an upright seated plunge and a 5-year warranty on the body. Both reach 37°F.
Do the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 and Plunge All-In both heat?
Yes. The Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 includes a 1 kW heater and sets up to 104°F. The Plunge All-In reaches 104°F only with its optional heater, which you choose at checkout. Both heat slowly, at roughly 4 to 6°F per hour per their makers.
What warranty comes with the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 and the Plunge All-In?
Renu covers the Cold Stoic 3.0 for 5 years on all components except the chiller, which gets 1 year unless you buy an extension within 364 days. Plunge covers the All-In for 1 year on everything. Renu expects owners to do most repairs and pay shipping, while Plunge pays parts and labor but voids coverage for missed monthly filter changes, disconnecting the app or adding ice.
What circuit do I need for a Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 or a Plunge All-In?
Renu says the Cold Stoic 3.0 plugs into a standard 120V, 15 amp outlet and recommends a dedicated circuit. Plunge requires a dedicated 120V, 20 amp circuit for the All-In and prohibits extension cords. Have an electrician check the outlet before delivery.
How is the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 delivered compared with the Plunge All-In?
Renu ships the Cold Stoic 3.0 free curbside in 3 to 5 weeks, and you move the 365 lb tank off the pallet yourself. Plunge offers the All-In with free in-home delivery to the first level in most zones, and in-stock units ship within 8 business days. Neither delivery includes connecting power.
How much electricity does the Renu Cold Stoic 3.0 use?
Renu's cut sheet lists a 24-hour average of 130 W while holding 40°F, about 3.1 kWh a day, with a 518 W peak while cooling. Heating averages 260 W over 24 hours at 100°F. Plunge does not publish a comparable wattage for the All-In Gen 2.
Sources we checked
Specifications were read from these documents on November 14, 2026. Makers change models; check the current manual before you buy.
- Renu Therapy Cold Stoic 3.0 product page (renutherapy.com, Nov 2026)
- Renu Therapy Cold Stoic 3.0 cut sheet (PDF)
- Renu Therapy Cold Stoic 3.0 User Manual v0.9 (PDF)
- Renu Therapy Specifications and Dimensions page
- Renu Therapy Cold Plunge Tank Limited Warranty (Home Use Only)
- Renu Therapy refund policy
- Plunge All-In Gen 2 product page and specifications (plunge.com, read via en-ca locale, Nov 2026)
- Plunge Help Center: Manual and Setup Guide for the Residential Plunge All-In (updated Nov 14, 2026)
- Plunge Help Center: Electrical Requirements for Plunge Cold-Plunge Models (updated Nov 14, 2026)
- Plunge All-In Residential 1-Year Limited Warranty (last revised Nov 13, 2026)
- Plunge Help Center: Caring for Your Residential Plunge All-In
- Renu Therapy launches Vero (press release, Nov 24, 2025)
- Plunge tech specs comparison page (older All-In figures)
