Quick answer

The Icetubs IceBarrel is the better plunge if you want a finished wood and stainless tub that chills to 37.4°F and heats to 100.4°F on its own engine, while the Ice Barrel 500 is the better buy if you want an insulated upright barrel at a fraction of the cost and are fine with ice or a separate chiller. They are not two versions of one product. Icetubs is a European maker sold in the US through Bathing Brands; Ice Barrel is a US company whose barrels are made in the USA from recycled plastic. On paper the Icetubs costs several times as much as the bare Ice Barrel and nearly twice the Ice Barrel 500 plus its Chiller.

At a glance

Icetubs

Icetubs IceBarrel (Standard and XL)

Thermowood and stainless barrel with 1 HP engine

Type
Chiller-integrated upright tub (heat and cool)
Price tier
Premium
Best for
Buyers who want a wood and stainless upright plunge that both chills and heats

Choose the Icetubs IceBarrel if you want a wood and stainless upright plunge that cools to 37.4°F and heats to 100.4°F from one included 1 HP engine.

Ice Barrel

Ice Barrel 500

Insulated plastic barrel, ice now, chiller later

Type
Insulated upright barrel (ice or add-on chiller)
Price tier
Budget
Best for
Buyers who want a light, insulated upright barrel for ice baths at entry cost

Choose the Ice Barrel 500 if you want a light, insulated upright barrel for ice baths at entry cost, with the option to add a 1/2 HP chiller later.

Search for "ice barrel" and you get two different companies. Ice Barrel (two words) is Ice Barrel Inc., a US brand that sells upright plastic barrels, currently the Ice Barrel 300 and Ice Barrel 500, plus a separate Ice Barrel Chiller. IceBarrel (one word) is a model made by Icetubs, a Dutch company (Icetubs B.V.) whose US distributor is Bathing Brands in Wheeling, Illinois. Icetubs also makes the IceBath, a reclining tub. Same idea (sit upright, water to the neck), very different products.

The Ice Barrel 400 that many buyers still remember is no longer listed on Ice Barrel's US site as of November 14, 2026; its old link redirects to the home page. The current full-size model is the Ice Barrel 500, so that is what we compare here. The Icetubs IceBarrel comes in Standard (stainless steel interior, about 92 gallons) and XL (fiberglass interior, about 114 gallons), each with optional matching stairs.

Key differences between Icetubs IceBarrel and Ice Barrel

  • Lowest set temperature: Icetubs IceBarrel 37.4 °F, Ice Barrel 37 °F.
  • Water capacity (Standard): Icetubs IceBarrel 92.5 gal, Ice Barrel 94 gal.
  • Cooling power: Icetubs IceBarrel 1 HP, Ice Barrel 0.5 HP.
  • Empty weight: Icetubs IceBarrel 327 lb, Ice Barrel 104 lb.
  • Filled weight: Icetubs IceBarrel 1,098 lb, Ice Barrel 900 lb.
  • Overall height: Icetubs IceBarrel 47 in, Ice Barrel 42.1 in.
  • Best for: Icetubs IceBarrel: Buyers who want a wood and stainless upright plunge that both chills and heats. Ice Barrel: Buyers who want a light, insulated upright barrel for ice baths at entry cost.

Icetubs IceBarrel vs Ice Barrel by the numbers

Head to head: the numbers that matter

Icetubs IceBarrelIce Barrel

Lowest set temperature[2]

Icetubs IceBarrel37.4 °F
Ice Barrel37 °F Edge

Lower is better · Ice Barrel 500 reaches 37°F only with the add-on Ice Barrel Chiller

Water capacity (Standard)[2]

Icetubs IceBarrel92.5 gal
Ice Barrel94 gal

IceBarrel XL holds 113.6 gal; the Icetubs manual rounds Standard to 92 gal

Cooling power[2]

Icetubs IceBarrel1 HP Edge
Ice Barrel0.5 HP

Higher is better · Icetubs engine is included; Ice Barrel Chiller is a separate purchase

Empty weight[1]

Icetubs IceBarrel327 lb
Ice Barrel104 lb Edge

Lower is better · Icetubs figure includes the engine and protector; the Ice Barrel Chiller adds 65 lb

Filled weight[1]

Icetubs IceBarrel1,098 lb
Ice Barrel900 lb Edge

Lower is better · Icetubs XL is 1,321 lb filled

Overall height[1]

Icetubs IceBarrel47 in
Ice Barrel42.1 in

IceBarrel stairs option raises the step-up height to about 54 in overall

How cold do bathhouses actually run? (SaunaShare data)

Coldest tub at each of the 65 SaunaShare bathhouses that publish a plunge temperature, out of 403 listings with a cold plunge. Median: 45°F.

Below 40°F9 bathhouses
40 to 44°F15 bathhouses
45 to 49°F25 bathhouses
50°F and up16 bathhouses

Lowest published setting: Icetubs IceBarrel 37.4°F, Ice Barrel 37°F. Most bathhouses run warmer than either floor.

Our scorecard (1 to 5, from published specs and our support history)
CategoryIcetubs IceBarrelIce Barrel
Build materialsIcetubs uses thermowood outside and 304 stainless (Standard) or fiberglass (XL) inside; Ice Barrel uses insulated recycled LLDPE plastic that can fade in sun.5/53/5
Temperature controlThe IceBarrel's 1 HP engine cools to 37.4°F and heats to 100.4°F per the US distributor spec; the Ice Barrel 500 is ice-only unless you add a 1/2 HP chiller.5/53/5
Upfront costThe Icetubs IceBarrel costs several times the bare Ice Barrel 500 and nearly twice the Ice Barrel 500 and Chiller bundle.2/55/5
Weight and placementThe IceBarrel weighs 327 lb empty and ships on a pallet; the Ice Barrel 500 weighs 104 lb empty.3/55/5
Water careIcetubs runs a 5 micron filter, ozone and a 15 gpm pump that turns the water over about every 6 minutes; Ice Barrel recommends a water change every four weeks.4/53/5
WarrantyIcetubs gives 2 years for private use but treats the pump and ozone generator as consumables; Ice Barrel gives a limited lifetime barrel warranty that its own terms cap at 3 years, and 1 year on the Chiller.3/54/5

Category ratings, not a total: which one wins depends on which rows matter to you.

Icetubs IceBarrel (Standard and XL) vs Ice Barrel 500: full specifications

SpecIcetubs IceBarrel (Standard and XL)Ice Barrel 500
Maker[1]Icetubs B.V. (Netherlands); US distributor Bathing BrandsIce Barrel Inc. (USA)
What it is[2]Upright tub with included 1 HP cooling and heating engineInsulated barrel; cool with ice or the separate Ice Barrel Chiller
Exterior size[1]Standard about 54 L x 31 W x 47 H in; XL about 62 x 41 x 47 in57.6 L x 30.7 W x 42.1 H in
Interior[2]26.8 in diameter, 26 in seating depth (Standard); 35.1 in diameter (XL)Built-in seat and steps; interior size not published
Water capacity[2]92.5 gal (Standard), 113.6 gal (XL)94 gal (356 L)
Weight empty / filled[1]327 / 1,098 lb (Standard); 373 / 1,321 lb (XL)104 / 900 lb
Temperature range[2]37.4 to 100.4°F37°F low with Chiller; no heating
Interior material[4]Stainless steel (Standard); fiberglass (XL)Recycled, BPA-free LLDPE plastic, R-16 foam
Exterior[4]Thermowood (species not published)UV-protected plastic shell plus cover
Filtration and sanitation[1]5 micron replaceable filter, built-in ozone, 15 gpm pumpWater Stabilizer; filter alerts on the Chiller
Electrical (US)[2]110V / 60Hz, 14.5 A max, 1.7 kW max input (distributor spec)Barrel: none. Chiller: about 115V, 60Hz, 15 A fuse rating
Engine noise[2]60 dB(A)Not published
Ambient limits[1]23 to 104°F engine on; 34 to 104°F engine offChiller rated for ambient up to 120°F; low limit not published
Vent clearance[1]20 in around the engineNot published on the product page
Filter and water change[1]Filter monthly; water every 1 to 2 months in daily useWater every four weeks or as preferred
Warranty[1]2 years private use; 6 months light professionalLimited lifetime, capped at 3 years (barrel); 1 year (Chiller)
Stairs[2]Optional matching thermowood stairs with handrailsBuilt-in steps

First, the name: IceBarrel is not Ice Barrel

If you remember one thing, make it this: the Icetubs IceBarrel and the Ice Barrel share a name and a body position, and nothing else. Different companies, different materials, different cooling, different warranties.

  • Icetubs IceBarrel: thermowood exterior, stainless steel (Standard) or fiberglass (XL) interior, and a 1 HP engine that both cools and heats. Sold in the US through Bathing Brands and its dealers, including Sauna Marketplace.
  • Ice Barrel 500: an insulated, made-in-USA plastic barrel with built-in steps and a seat. No engine. Cool it with ice, or buy the separate Ice Barrel Chiller.

If a listing says "IceBarrel XL", that is Icetubs. If it says "Ice Barrel 300", "400" or "500", that is Ice Barrel Inc.

Cooling and heating

The Icetubs IceBarrel ships with its engine. The US distributor spec lists a 1 HP engine, cooling to 37.4°F, heating to 100.4°F, a 15 gpm pump and a 1.7 kW maximum input. The Icetubs manual says the full water volume circulates about every 6 minutes, and recommends running the engine at least 6 hours a day so the water never sits stagnant.

One detail to confirm when you order: Icetubs' own European site sells the heater as an option, and the manual describes heating "with heater function purchased." The US distributor and the Sauna Marketplace listing describe the engine as heating and cooling. Ask for the exact configuration in writing.

The Ice Barrel 500 has no engine. Ice Barrel says its R-16 foam walls and lid often hold water around 59°F without a chiller running, which tells you about insulation, not cooling. For a set temperature you add the 1/2 HP Ice Barrel Chiller, which cools to 37°F, connects to the barrel's 3/4 inch chiller ports, and does not heat.

Materials and build

This is where the price gap comes from. The Icetubs IceBarrel Standard is thermowood around a 304 stainless steel interior and seat; the XL swaps in a fiberglass insert for a wider 35.1 inch interior. Icetubs' own site recommends the XL for people over 6'2".

The Ice Barrel 500 is recycled, BPA-free LLDPE plastic with R-16 polyurethane foam in the walls and lid. It is tough and light (104 lb empty), and it fits users up to 6'9". Ice Barrel's warranty is honest that the plastic will fade in direct sun.

Coastal owners: the Icetubs warranty excludes corrosion damage when the tub is placed within 10 miles of the coast, and Icetubs warns that stainless steel can rust near the sea. If you live near salt air, factor that in before choosing stainless.

Install, wiring and where the heat goes

The IceBarrel arrives on a pallet by freight, with a shipping weight of about 375 lb for the Standard. Plan the path from the curb before delivery day. Filled, the Standard puts about 1,098 lb on the floor and the XL about 1,321 lb.

Electrically, the US distributor lists 110V / 60Hz with a 14.5 A maximum current. The Icetubs manual on file is the European 220 to 230V document, so use the US nameplate. Our electrical read: a load that can draw 14.5 A for hours belongs on its own 20 amp circuit, because a long-running load should stay under 80% of the breaker rating. Have an electrician confirm it against the nameplate and your local code. The manual requires a grounded, GFCI-protected outlet and 20 inches of clear space around the engine.

Indoors, remember physics. The Icetubs manual says the engine gives off about 3 kW of heat into the room at full power, so a closet or small bathroom will heat up fast. The Ice Barrel 500 with ice needs no power at all; the Chiller lists a 15 A fuse rating and should sit in shade with room to vent.

Water care, winter and warranty fine print

Icetubs asks for daily wipe-downs, weekly AquaFinesse and filter checks, a new 5 micron filter every month, and a full water change every 1 to 2 months. Only AquaFinesse is approved: salts, chlorine, magnesium and shock doses void the warranty. Ice Barrel recommends changing water every four weeks, with its Water Stabilizer.

For winter, the Icetubs engine is rated for 23 to 104°F air when running and 34 to 104°F when off; below that, drain the tub and engine. Heating does not change that rule.

Warranty headlines need context. Icetubs gives 2 years for private use, but lists the water pump and the ozone generator as consumables outside coverage, and labor and call-out fees are not included. Ice Barrel gives a limited lifetime warranty on the barrel, capped at 3 years by its terms (fading, weather and delamination after the first year excluded) and 1 year on the Chiller.

Daily use: getting in, sitting down, and noise

Both are upright plunges: you sit with water to your neck instead of lying back. The Icetubs IceBarrel Standard has a 47 inch tall rim, a 26.8 inch interior diameter and a 26 inch seating depth, with a stainless seat that sits over the filter. That rim is a real step for shorter users, which is why Icetubs sells matching thermowood stairs with stainless handrails. With stairs, the Standard grows to about 62 inches long and 54 inches tall overall, so measure for the stairs version if you plan to add them later.

The Ice Barrel 500 is 42.1 inches tall with built-in steps and an internal seat, and Ice Barrel lists users up to 6'9". Its interior dimensions are not published.

Noise only matters for the Icetubs (an ice-fed Ice Barrel is silent). Icetubs lists 60 dB(A) at 1 meter for the engine, and the manual suggests a cooling schedule if the engine hum bothers you at night, while noting the energy savings are small because the engine idles in automatic mode. Both the Icetubs engine and the Ice Barrel Chiller can be controlled from an app over Wi-Fi.

Total cost and who should buy which

The honest framing: the Ice Barrel 500 is a Budget tub, and the Ice Barrel 500 plus Chiller is a Mid-tier setup. The Icetubs IceBarrel is a Premium piece of outdoor furniture with a heat pump inside. On paper the Icetubs costs nearly twice the Ice Barrel bundle, and in exchange you get a 1 HP engine instead of 1/2 HP, heating to 100.4°F, ozone, 5 micron filtration, stainless or fiberglass instead of plastic, and thermowood outside.

Buy the Icetubs IceBarrel if the plunge is part of a sauna or spa space you care about visually, you want hot and cold from one cabinet, and you can give it a dedicated circuit and 20 inches of breathing room. Pick the XL if you are over 6'2" or broad-shouldered.

Buy the Ice Barrel 500 if you want to start ice baths now, keep weight and cost down, or plunge somewhere with no power. Add the Chiller if ice runs become a chore. For more on what cold water does and does not do, see our cold plunge benefits page.

The verdict

Which one should you buy?

Choose Icetubs IceBarrel if

  • You want one unit that chills to 37.4°F and heats to 100.4°F
  • The plunge will sit in view and you want wood and stainless
  • You want ozone and 5 micron filtration built in

Choose Ice Barrel if

  • You want the lowest cost way to start ice baths
  • You want a 104 lb barrel that needs no outlet for ice baths
  • You live within 10 miles of the ocean

Choose the Icetubs IceBarrel if you want a wood and stainless upright plunge that cools to 37.4°F and heats to 100.4°F from one included 1 HP engine. Choose the Ice Barrel 500 if you want a light, insulated upright barrel for ice baths at entry cost, with the option to add a 1/2 HP chiller later.

FAQ

Is the Icetubs IceBarrel the same as the Ice Barrel?

No. The Icetubs IceBarrel is made by Icetubs, a Dutch company, and is a thermowood and stainless steel tub with a built-in 1 HP cooling and heating engine. The Ice Barrel is made by Ice Barrel Inc., a US company, and is an insulated plastic barrel cooled with ice or a separate Ice Barrel Chiller.

Which is better, the Icetubs IceBarrel or the Ice Barrel 500?

The Icetubs IceBarrel is better if you want automatic cold down to 37.4°F, heat up to 100.4°F and premium materials in one unit. The Ice Barrel 500 is better if budget and weight matter most, since it weighs 104 lb empty and costs a fraction of the Icetubs IceBarrel. Ice Barrel 500 owners who want a set temperature need the separate 1/2 HP Ice Barrel Chiller.

What is the difference between the IceBarrel Standard and XL?

The Icetubs IceBarrel Standard has a stainless steel interior, a 26.8 inch interior diameter and holds 92.5 gallons. The Icetubs IceBarrel XL has a fiberglass interior, a 35.1 inch interior diameter and holds 113.6 gallons. Icetubs recommends the XL for people over 6'2".

Does the Icetubs IceBarrel need a special outlet?

The US distributor lists the Icetubs IceBarrel at 110V / 60Hz with a 14.5 A maximum current, and the Icetubs manual requires a grounded, GFCI-protected outlet. Because the Icetubs IceBarrel can draw close to 15 A for long periods, we recommend a dedicated 20 amp circuit confirmed by an electrician against the nameplate.

Is the Ice Barrel 400 still sold?

The Ice Barrel 400 is no longer listed on Ice Barrel's US site as of November 14, 2026, and its product link redirects to the home page. Ice Barrel's current models are the Ice Barrel 300 and Ice Barrel 500, plus the Ice Barrel Chiller. The Icetubs IceBarrel is a separate product from a different company and is still sold through Bathing Brands dealers.

Does the Ice Barrel 500 heat the water?

No. The Ice Barrel 500 has no engine, and the add-on Ice Barrel Chiller cools to 37°F but does not heat. If you want warm soaks as well as cold plunges in one upright tub, the Icetubs IceBarrel lists heating to 100.4°F on its 1 HP engine; confirm the heater is included in the configuration you order.

Can the Icetubs IceBarrel stay outside in winter?

The Icetubs IceBarrel can be installed outdoors, but the Icetubs manual limits air temperature to 23 to 104°F with the engine running and 34 to 104°F with it off. Below those limits the Icetubs IceBarrel and its engine must be drained, and freeze damage is not covered by the warranty.

Sources we checked

Specifications were read from these documents on November 14, 2026. Makers change models; check the current manual before you buy.

  1. Icetubs Operation and Maintenance Manual, July 30, 2026 (hosted by Sauna Marketplace)
  2. Icetubs IceBarrel spec page, SteamSaunaBath (Bathing Brands, US distributor)
  3. Icetubs IceBarrel XL spec page, SteamSaunaBath (Bathing Brands, US distributor)
  4. IceBarrel product page, icetubs.com
  5. Icetubs IceBarrel Hot and Cold Plunge, Sauna Marketplace
  6. Ice Barrel 500 product page, icebarrel.com (Oct 2026 version)
  7. Ice Barrel Chiller product page, icebarrel.com (Oct 2026 version)
  8. Ice Barrel product warranty and Chiller limited warranty, icebarrel.com
  9. Ice Barrel FAQ, icebarrel.com
  10. Ice Barrel home page lineup, icebarrel.com (read Nov 14, 2026)
  11. Ice Barrel 400 product page, archived Oct 22, 2025 (Internet Archive)